bringing in magner

[bedford]

not sure who to get rid of for magner, if one of the above GWS players isnt named then he automatically comes in for the one not named, but if all are named im not too sure who would be best to take out for magner unless i wait a till before round 3 to trade him in if he kills it, if not wont bother, but would waste a trade by doing this  :-\

anyone else got this problem?

[supercoach addict]

IMO should take out Clifton and put in Magner.

[ben_020285]

Magner in for Wingard and then with that extra cash you can make an upgrade somewhere else!

[Talisman]

I'd say bring him in for Clifton as 3 from any team on 1 line (i.e. mids in this case) is a bit risky - esp. GWS if they rotate players the way GC did last year. Also, Wingard could be a great point of difference (haven't seen him in nearly as many teams as Clifton/Shiel/Miles) & not certain Clifton is in Giants' best 22 (esp. once injured players return) - only played a half against the Tigers when GWS seemed to have their best possible midfield rotation in action. Clifton will be a good, mature body around the stoppages, but not convinced he provides that much value around the ground. Just my thoughts.