Luke Parker or Josh Caddy

[whynot102]

Peoples thoughts

[ClarksonsArmy]

Parker better JS

[Fletch74]

Parker better JS

:o How do you determine that?

[ClarksonsArmy]

look at NAB Cup and gametime

Caddy has a lot of competition

[Bruizer81]

Totally disagree  :o
Caddy has the security that Parker does
Caddy spent another 2 weeks in Arizona
NAB cup figures are misleading

[SydneyRox]

There is nothing wrong with Parkers JS. He played 13 games last year in his debut season and will play more this year mainly through the midfield. A word of warning is the he may end up a vest victim a couple of times as well..... but I could same the same about Caddy

[Bruizer81]

I doubt neither will see much of the vest
Hard inside midfielders are much needed in todays game
Plus with a couple of preseasons they are ready to step up

[specky lecky]

Caddy is one of the most highly regarded mids up on the gc. The vest will go to first year players, caddy they need on the ground. I would say caddy has better js for that reason. Parker has has his fair share of the vest and is ready to cement himself in the best 22 as okeefes prodigy

[afl_freak2]

not sure on all the caddy hype!! anyone keen to say why hes so good for his price (in dreamteam that is) as his supercoach avg was quite a big dif in the 2 games he played,i take it hes a ball butcher in supercoach??? or if that miss leading??

[Capper]

personally i dont see a problem with either players js, its just up to who you think will score more

[2 large cokes]

not sure on all the caddy hype!! anyone keen to say why hes so good for his price (in dreamteam that is) as his supercoach avg was quite a big dif in the 2 games he played,i take it hes a ball butcher in supercoach??? or if that miss leading??

you have to remember he played 2 games towards the end of the year after an injury ravished year. was a first year player also. another pre season under his belt. his going to be gun. great disposal as well. you don't get drafted at 7 I think for no reason (well most of the time lol). deffinatly in gc best 22 if not best 12 when up and running. is a bargain in my opinion!

[SydneyRox]

Caddy is one of the most highly regarded mids up on the gc. The vest will go to first year players, caddy they need on the ground. I would say caddy has better js for that reason. Parker has has his fair share of the vest and is ready to cement himself in the best 22 as okeefes prodigy

Jude Bolton, not ROK