NEED FEEDBACK

Started by blake_scooby66, March 19, 2012, 10:16:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

blake_scooby66

DEF: goddard, deledio, suckling, lake, clarke, smedts, bugg. sub: ellis, yagmoor
MID: ablett, swan, watson, mzungu, dangerfield, ledger. sub: magner, gibson
RUCK: cox, mcintosh. sub: giles, redden
FWD: franklin, goodes, fyfe, martin, porplyzia, zorko, cameron. sub: weedon, kerridge

what do you think? wat rookies are the best ?

johnnytheboy1

Backs: First of all you are 1 premium short in defence so your team will struggle here.I would have Darley & Morris ahead of Smedts at the moment.
Mids: Nice unique in Mzungu your team is the first i have seen him in so should make a POD. Dangerfield will have a breakout year.
Rucks: If you going to go for a mid Price Ruckmen i think you are better off with Kreuzer.
Fwds: The only player i wouldn't have in your starting line up is Zorkoas he may not play in Round 1.

Overall: Your team has some problems particularly up back. I give it a 7/10

blake_scooby66

im hoping on lake to be the extra one

cuz_crew

I agree with Johnny... although your backs are fine.

mzungu is too risky.

mcintosh is a waste of money. giles will score the same as him, get rid of him.

use the money to upgrade your mid to 4 premiums (watson, mzungu and dangerfield are not premiums)

7 out of 10

blake_scooby66

hows this ?

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Suckling, Lake, Clarke, Bugg, Morris. SUB: Spur, Darley
MID: Ablett, Swan, Watson, Dangerfield, C.Smith, Ledger. SUB: Shiel, Magner
RUCK: Cox, Mumford. SUB: Giles, Redden
FWD: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, D.Smith, Pfeiffer, Cameron. SUB: Smedts, Dickson

Any rookies that look starters for round 1?
Go for another premium in the backline (Broughton) instead of lake ?

blake_scooby66