If both named...Shaw (Adel) or Smedts (Geel)

[enzedder]

As title suggests trying to finalise back rookies.

[Mozza3]

Smedts looks the better option if named but it appears he's long odds to get named.

[enzedder]

Smedts looks the better option if named but it appears he's long odds to get named.

This is what I've been reading too.
I'm not too keen on loading up my rookie defenders from just Richmond and GWS but looks the safest play at this stage.

[jasonweare]

Smedts looks the better option if named but it appears he's long odds to get named.

This is what I've been reading too.
I'm not too keen on loading up my rookie defenders from just Richmond and GWS but looks the safest play at this stage.

That's where I'm at at the moment

[cortez]

the fun thing is ive got ellis, morris, smedts and bugg. if smedts isnt picked i cant just go and put darley in cause he already would have played. its a hard situation to be in but i reckon scotty loves smedtsy to much not to pick him.

[quinny88]

the fun thing is ive got ellis, morris, smedts and bugg. if smedts isnt picked i cant just go and put darley in cause he already would have played. its a hard situation to be in but i reckon scotty loves smedtsy to much not to pick him.

I would pick darley over smedts anyway

[cortez]

and that is why our teams will be different. smedts is a better player than darley imo.

[The Bomber]

yagmoor???i thought he played quite well in the NAB cup...

[no eye deer]

yagmoor???i thought he played quite well in the NAB cup...

Yeah, I thought so too, but wasn't  subbed on until half time on the weekend for 8 disposals and Clarke played most of the game, so maybe not so good JS?