will average 2300 by round 11! has PICTURE. please rate

Started by punter_33, March 19, 2012, 08:44:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

punter_33





Have since traded
- newman to deledio
- grimes to scotland
- cox to hale

Really wanted to go newman over deledio as every single person has him but think he is too good to overlook.

DCAK

Is this a joke?

DEF: Forster -1 (who is he?), Young -1 (who is he?). With current set up 1 x donut.
MID: Zorko -1 (injured), Magner -1 (injured), Shiel -1 (Magoos), Mitchell -1 (rehab?). 2 x donuts.
RUCK: Ok.
FWD: Walsh -1 (on the pine), Weedon (vest it up!), Smedts (Cats best 22...doubtful)

Poor choice of rookies. Don't like Coniglio @ M4, lacking midfield depth.

5/10.

johnnytheboy1

Backs: Obviously you are not worried about the bye in round 13 as you will cop a few donuts with that team.Replace forster & Young with Bugg & Ellis
Mids: Zorko,Mitchell & Shiel are not likely to play., Look at players such as Kennedy & Ledger. The rest of the team is ok.
Rucks: David Hale should score well.
Fwds: Very strong except for walsh & Smedts who ihaven't shown much over preseason.

Overall: You need to fix up your rookie selection you have only 11 Premiums 1 short.I rate your team a 7/10

quinny88

Quote from: DCAK on March 19, 2012, 09:40:17 PM
Is this a joke?

DEF: Forster -1 (who is he?), Young -1 (who is he?). With current set up 1 x donut.
MID: Zorko -1 (injured), Magner -1 (injured), Shiel -1 (Magoos), Mitchell -1 (rehab?). 2 x donuts.
RUCK: Ok.
FWD: Walsh -1 (on the pine), Weedon (vest it up!), Smedts (Cats best 22...doubtful)

Poor choice of rookies. Don't like Coniglio @ M4, lacking midfield depth.

5/10.

Agree with some of this but think you need to.check some of your facts before Tee-ing off on someone
-Magner is fine and will play rd 1, rd 2 at the latest..
-Shiel played one game in the magoos because he came back from injury and got a ton of the ball, he will kill it.
-Chris scott has voiced his love for smedts, he will play (may not score well.however)
-Rucks ok? Its the best combination available appart from cox/mummy imo
- & last but not least coniglio is a solid d4.. Plenty of teams are going with a 3 prem mid because of the fact that there are loads of gun rookies in that area..

Some of your rookies deffinetly need adjusting, do a bit of research and u will.be well on your way to a solid side