Who will drop first? *POLL*

Started by Madsnake, March 19, 2012, 11:27:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which of these Bye rd 13 defenders is over priced and will drop in cash?

Carrazzo $454,800
10 (34.5%)
Deledio $452,100
0 (0%)
Scotland $493,500
19 (65.5%)
Birchall $443,500
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Madsnake

Can't Decide out of which of these four to start, which ones will kill it and who'll drop off a bit for a perfect upgrade later on.

Currently have Deledio and Birchall and think that i will leave scotland out for now and upgrade to the old boy later but Carrazzo is really catching my eye and is also quite unique..

Thoughts?

mezzoculo

From what I've seen this preseason, there is a fair chance that Carrazzo will play the sweeping defender / midfielder role vacated by Gibbs. Hopefully that means fewer tagging roles!

Madsnake

Quote from: mezzoculo on March 19, 2012, 12:02:28 PM
From what I've seen this preseason, there is a fair chance that Carrazzo will play the sweeping defender / midfielder role vacated by Gibbs. Hopefully that means fewer tagging roles!

That's making it even harder for me not to pick him...
Got a feeling he will kill it this year but so will all the rest of them..

Cicjose


mezzoculo

Quote from: Madsnake on March 19, 2012, 01:07:52 PM
Quote from: mezzoculo on March 19, 2012, 12:02:28 PM
From what I've seen this preseason, there is a fair chance that Carrazzo will play the sweeping defender / midfielder role vacated by Gibbs. Hopefully that means fewer tagging roles!

That's making it even harder for me not to pick him...
Got a feeling he will kill it this year but so will all the rest of them..
If it helps, I just swapped Scotland for Carrots...

Justin Bieber

Carrots or Scotland.

Where Goddard?

Madsnake

Quote from: whatlez on March 19, 2012, 01:46:32 PM
Carrots or Scotland.

Where Goddard?

Not keen on Goddard this year, just don't want him. also i'm going for a bit more of a unique outlook.

TheMailman

Whose to say any of these will drop in price?

Carrazo looks good
Scotland is always Good
Delidio and Birchall both look to be increasing their output

mezzoculo

Quote from: TheMailman on March 19, 2012, 05:16:05 PM
Whose to say any of these will drop in price?

Carrazo looks good
Scotland is always Good
Delidio and Birchall both look to be increasing their output
Being 'good' doesn't exclude your price dropping for whatever reason, MM.

TheMailman

By good I mean maintaining/increasing their average

Carrazo had many tagging roles that look to be eleviated

Scotland is a grey area, I can't really tell

Delidio has just matured more with more midfield time and Birchall is similar except along half back

Picking Goddard as an upgrade target is just stupid IMO. Had a shocking DT year last year.

The only one shaping up for an upgrade target is Scotland and I doubt he would drop much either

mezzoculo

Quote from: TheMailman on March 19, 2012, 05:35:35 PM
By good I mean maintaining/increasing their average

Carrazo had many tagging roles that look to be eleviated

Scotland is a grey area, I can't really tell

Delidio has just matured more with more midfield time and Birchall is similar except along half back

Picking Goddard as an upgrade target is just stupid IMO. Had a shocking DT year last year.

The only one shaping up for an upgrade target is Scotland and I doubt he would drop much either
Which is what the poll says...

Agree on Goddard.

TheMailman

And I said, based on his consistancy I'd say Scotland increase his price over the first 11 rounds or so he wouldn't really drop in price either

Well I didn't say it, but I meant it  :P