Bower or guthrie?

[cich_189]

Guthrie or bower? Guthrie has been more impressive pre season dont like bower at all as a player and think once laidler jameson get back hell struggle to get games. guthrie 30k more but really like the look of him... thoughts?

[afl_freak2]

none of them

[cich_189]

like anyone around the price... already have marty clark, ellis and bugg

[Footyrulz]

just get a cheaper rookie

[The Bomber]

just get a cheaper rookie

+1 dont have to worry about their position in the team (given you pick the right rookie)

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Neither have any appeal in any respect. Perhaps go with a decent rookie unless you can go a bit higher price wise. Not many have looked at Brodie Martin. A definite risk but played some great footy in his first season, unfortunately that was a while ago. Goodluck and cheers.