Who is starting with Swan?

Started by lollipop man, March 18, 2012, 07:19:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Are you starting with Swan?

Yes
30 (43.5%)
No
39 (56.5%)

Total Members Voted: 3

lollipop man

Quote from: Windigo on March 18, 2012, 07:53:02 PM
Interesting, I did a poll on who was going with Swan a few weeks back and most votes were for "I'm going with Swan."
Yeah i think a lot of people have been scared off by his poor scores so far in the NAB, maybe?

elephants

I don't like paying 600k for someone that is off to Arizona mid-year and potentially missing 2 games WITHOUT injury...

Windigo

Fair point......Wonder if I should do another "Rocky Vs Swan Re-Loaded" topic....

I am partial to bit of Red-Rock.. :P

aces-high


zeus123456

Why would anyone not want to start with Swan  ??? . He is a dt champion and who cares if he hasn't done good in NAB cup, it's NAB cup for god sakes, he never tries at NAB cup. He is definitely a starter for me and I think it will be a loss for whoever doesn't start him when he pumps those 130+! Oh yeahhhhhhh  ;D

lollipop man

I know a lot of people have been saying Swan went shower last year in the NAB cup too but that's not entirely true. Just looked through his last years NAB scores and they were as follows: 125, 94, 77, compared to 61, 66 and 66 from this year....

elephants

Quote from: lollipop man on March 18, 2012, 09:40:04 PM
I know a lot of people have been saying Swan went shower last year in the NAB cup too but that's not entirely true. Just looked through his last years NAB scores and they were as follows: 125, 94, 77, compared to 61, 66 and 66 from this year....
Woah that is surprising!!
I am not too keen on forking out 600k for someone I could bring in within the first 8 round for 500 odd...

Chelskiman

Quote from: elephants on March 18, 2012, 07:21:53 PM
After hurling abuse at everyone who wasn't starting with Swanny I have decided too to upgrade to him after Arizona...

Same.  :-[

elephants

Quote from: Chelskiman on March 18, 2012, 10:05:31 PM
Quote from: elephants on March 18, 2012, 07:21:53 PM
After hurling abuse at everyone who wasn't starting with Swanny I have decided too to upgrade to him after Arizona...

Same.  :-[
Hahahahaha :)

PowerBug

Why do people not have Swan?? :O

elephants

Quote from: PowerBug on March 18, 2012, 10:53:24 PM
Why do people not have Swan?? :O
Because we have spent too long looking at our teams over Summer that we get bored of seeing him there so we trade him...

Jukes

I wish I could start with Swanny. I really do. He will be the highest scoring player. I just think other players offer better value  from the premium mids (*cough* Stanton *cough*). Will be the first upgrade target in the middle for me, hoping that'll be relatively early if McCarthy booms a high-90s average like his NAB cup form is suggesting.

underdog11

54% will regret your disgraceful decision. It's Dane Swan for crying out loud, just look at his numbers!

Holz

Quote from: underdog11 on March 19, 2012, 12:09:12 AM
54% will regret your disgraceful decision. It's Dane Swan for crying out loud, just look at his numbers!

depends who you bring in for him, i had him out of my team for a day for pendles, woke up the next day looked at my team imagined my opponent having Swan 330  and put him back in

zeus123456

Quote from: underdog11 on March 19, 2012, 12:09:12 AM
54% will regret your disgraceful decision. It's Dane Swan for crying out loud, just look at his numbers!
100% agree! Dane is an out an out superstar, how can you not start with this freak. Don't worry bro we'll be getting the 130+ scores at the start ;)