Hopefully nearly there!!!

[plugger36]

Here it is:

Backs: Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Malceski, Tomlinson (Brown, Wilkes)

Centres: Ablett, Swan, Boyd, McDonald, Ledge, Magner (Gibson, Kerridge)

Rucks: Cox, Giles (Stephenson, Campbell)

Forwards: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Harvey, Porps, d.smith, smeldts (Couch, hampton)

Is it to backline heavy?
Should I downgrade a defender and get a premium in midfeild?

thoughts??

[Saintsational18]

Good looking team maybe you've got 1 to many prems in backline I'd downgrade one to Dempsey, Bradon Ellis and upgrade someone in the mids maybe to Dangerfield or something I rate it 8/10 pretty good but 1 or two more improvements needed

[dmac07]

PRetty good, I like the stacked backline, I think mid pricers in the mids this yea is a no no, so I'd say leave the mids as is unless you can afford to get in somelike like penles/murphy/selwood. Only other question would be over Harvey in the forwards, think someone like Cloke or Martin has more upside.

[tor01doc]

Maybe a bit greedy down back. Is Malceski really necessary @ D6 given the other picks?

Good mids - don't fiddle.

Rucks fine.

Harvey could be fine if you rate him but this line could be better.