Waters VS Duffman

[Adamant]

Beau Waters                  VS              Paul Duffield
2010 Games: 21                            2010 Games: 22
2010 Average: 87.5                       2010 Average: 87.6
80+ Scores: 12                              80+ Scores: 15
Below 60 Scores: 3                         Below 60 Scores: 3
Ceiling: 155                                   Ceiling: 135
Season Low: 49                              Season Low: 54
2012 NAB Cup Scores: 90 & 93       2012 NAB Cup Scores: 98, 81 & 81

Who is the better pick?         

[Justin Bieber]

Can't split them on those stats. But I say neither or Duffield.

[Ziplock]

or...

both?

:P

[Jukes]

Get Duffman. Has been a proven high-80s averager and has been on form this NAB cup, in the top few for dockers every game.

[Rommas]

I would take Waters if durability was never an issue, but it is, so go Duffield  ;)

[Hiro]

really tough to split them hmm.. if you can fit them both into your team i think they're both worth the risk at there price

[BBosCo]

yeh go duffman. waters struggled playing a full game tonight so i can see him being subbed off quite a bit during the season. imo wont average over 65

[Holz]

waters easy, the eagles basically have had a full squad out there most weeks, freo still have their best 2 midfielders to come back and shake things up. Both could peform but waters is much safer in terms of scoring ability in my opinion.

[elephants]

Get Duffman. Has been a proven high-80s averager and has been on form this NAB cup, in the top few for dockers every game.

Put your Eagles hate behind you bro ;)

Waters, easy.

[Ziplock]

both will have a better DT season than eachother :P

[Bak2Form]

duff has less chance of injury, i think they will both be around an 80 average