LOCK IT IN YES OR NO PLEASE give me the changes needed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[whynot102]

Backs
Goddard, H Shaw, Birchall, B Ellis, B Waters, Lake, M Clarke    Darley & Bugg

Centre
Ablett, Boyd, Mitchell, Selwood, K Stevens, J McDonald   J Magner & S Gigson

Rucks
Mummy, McEvoy    Giles & Stephenson

Forwards
Buddy, Fyfe, Martin, McGlynn, Porpis, Zorko, Treloar,  Smedts & T Couch

Please give me suggested changes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Dilen9]

Backs
Goddard, H Shaw, Birchall, B Ellis, B Waters, Lake, M Clarke    Darley & Bugg

Centre
Ablett, Boyd, Mitchell, Selwood, K Stevens, J McDonald   J Magner & S Gigson

Rucks
Mummy, McEvoy    Giles & Stephenson

Forwards
Buddy, Fyfe, Martin, McGlynn, Porpis, Zorko, Treloar,  Smedts & T Couch

Please give me suggested changes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Thanks for rating my team, mate, I will rate yours.
BCK: Strong backline, beau waters is not a great choice, haven't really seen him in the nab cup. Marty Clarke can be replaced with a young rookie, and then you can bank around 50000.
MID: not bad, but j McDonald will probably not get to play all of the games, replace him witha different young gun.
RCK: great, but maybe you could replace McEvoy, your choice mate.
FWD: zorko is not a good idea, he hasn't played nab cup, TOO much mid pricers, get a premium in there. Other than that it is alright.

OVERALL- good team, but needs some improving in some of the positions. 6/10, but has a potential of a 8/10 or a 9/10

[tor01doc]

D: Still Waters run deep into trouble. Out! Clarke could be OK but as ynot says - a good rookie is going to make you more money.

M: V strong. I prefer only 3 mids to start, but all 4 of yours are going to be there all year so as long as your D and F rookies make you cash, that'll be fine. Just seems the better rookies are mids.

R: Love it. Maybe Redden instead of Stephenson. Or go 3 rookies and aim to get Cox later. Seems your 4 mids will force one other line to be a bit weaker, so maybe here. Keep Mummy and get in Redden?

F: Ahh. Your weak line. McGlynn really can have flat patches. Zorko has been injured until now so maybe wait and see if he's recovered. You need to squeeze an extra premium in here. Maybe a slightly cheaper and therefore riskier one like Danger / Gray / Sidebottom or even Lewis for Hawthorn who scores well.

Could juggle things a bit and really balance things more.

Good luck.