Sidebottom vs. Gray

Started by lollipop man, March 16, 2012, 08:15:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one?

Sidebottom
24 (72.7%)
Gray
9 (27.3%)

Total Members Voted: 3

lollipop man

Ideally would have both but one has had to make way for Fyfe.

Justin Bieber

I don't really know who to vote for here.... have them both so neither.

lollipop man

Quote from: whatlez on March 16, 2012, 08:16:23 PM
I don't really know who to vote for here.... have them both so neither.
Yeah i've had both for a while now and really do want both but would mean having a 6 premium fwd line and a VERY weak backline with very questionable rookies.

DT-SC


Justin Bieber

Quote from: lollipop man on March 16, 2012, 08:18:05 PM
Quote from: whatlez on March 16, 2012, 08:16:23 PM
I don't really know who to vote for here.... have them both so neither.
Yeah i've had both for a while now and really do want both but would mean having a 6 premium fwd line and a VERY weak backline with very questionable rookies.
Yeah I want to do the same, but you can't. PM your forwardline and I'll tell you which one.

essendon2

Quote from: lollipop man on March 16, 2012, 08:18:05 PM
Quote from: whatlez on March 16, 2012, 08:16:23 PM
I don't really know who to vote for here.... have them both so neither.
Yeah i've had both for a while now and really do want both but would mean having a 6 premium fwd line and a VERY weak backline with very questionable rookies.
+1

because you have to have 4 of either Franklin, Fyfe, Pavlich, Cloke or Martin + Sidebottom/Gray

lollipop man

A lazy 116 for Gray tonight.  :P

Colliwobblers

i have sidebottom due to him being in the better team and port has the 3rd hardest draw so no help for gray there, can see myself bringing him in through the season however he is looking very very good, but like you i cant start both with buddy fyfe and martin in also. And taken the punt on dangerman

Zombie2.5

I've got both, try to otherwise i reckon sidebottom, mostly what colli said.

underdog11

Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 17, 2012, 12:33:11 AM
i have sidebottom due to him being in the better team and port has the 3rd hardest draw so no help for gray there, can see myself bringing him in through the season however he is looking very very good, but like you i cant start both with buddy fyfe and martin in also. And taken the punt on dangerman

Collingwood have the hardest draw

Colliwobblers

+1 collingwood does, but then collingwood can handle a tough draw better than port i think :)

still port looked great again tonight and are a different team to last season, anyone would have thrashed melbourne tonight but still i thinnk the power will have a much better season this year, no west coast turn around but i can see them winning a bunch more games and the important thinkg "being competative" most games.

Jukes

Sidey by a mile, great lad and will average close to 100.

Slap

Side bottom for me over gray purely because he won't cop the number one tag ahead of swan or pendles.

But that being said I have both.

Holz

Quote from: Slap on March 17, 2012, 04:18:11 AM
Side bottom for me over gray purely because he won't cop the number one tag ahead of swan or pendles.

But that being said I have both.

will gray get it though, he mights get the number 1 forward tag (if he plays forward) but i assume he would be behind boak and maybee hartlett if he gets up and going

Slap

i guess i just think there are more people in front of sidebottom than gray.

That being said, both sidey and gray have earnt BOG's before.