Backline Qualms

[JKraz]

Scotland, Goddard, Shaw/Delideo, Lake, Hargraves, Clarke, Ellis (Smedts, Bugg)

Very intersted to know some thoughts

Lids will come into my side if he plays well this week as he is far more consistent than Shaw....if he plays terrible then shaw it is.

Otherwise some feedback would be great as I think the backline is by far the hardest line in the side this year

[Jukes]

Wouldn't go for Lake but the rest is good.

[JKraz]

who would you recommend for lake?

[Holz]

who would you recommend for lake?

i would recomend grimes and malceski i have both, but im sure alot of people will disagree with me

[JKraz]

who would you recommend for lake?

i would recomend grimes and malceski i have both, but im sure alot of people will disagree with me

Yeah I dont think any are standout better selections than lake...

[JKraz]

would love to know why 2 people think its terrible?

[Holz]

who would you recommend for lake?

i would recomend grimes and malceski i have both, but im sure alot of people will disagree with me

Yeah I dont think any are standout better selections than lake...

well eski and grimes could both average 85+ and be keepers i dont think lake can be a keeper so would go up to shaw or deledio or down to a rookie if you dont like my midpricers

[TheMailman]

Its a good backline

But I wouldn't be judging Shaw v Delidio based on one match. Research them up some more.

Otherwise I wouldn't be changing it much

[Justin Bieber]

You have Hargrave, you don't need lake.

[oldshepp]

who would you recommend for lake?

i would recomend grimes and malceski i have both, but im sure alot of people will disagree with me

The eski's not even guaranteed a game this year is he?   Some of the Swans "best 22" sides don't have him in it.  If Lake remains fit he will play every week

[TheMailman]

Malceski will be lucky to get 10 games let alone 22

Lake looks like an ok option as does Hargraves

[Holz]

Malceski will be lucky to get 10 games let alone 22

Lake looks like an ok option as does Hargraves

i took out eski and put in waters

[TheMailman]

Malceski will be lucky to get 10 games let alone 22

Lake looks like an ok option as does Hargraves

i took out eski and put in waters

Yeah that sounds like a good swap

[Colliwobblers]

i voted solid, lids and shaw will both be top 6 defenders again this season so i wouldn't worry about that decision much.

Lake is the weakest link but as you say he will play all games he is uninjured for, i frefer hargrave over him and if you had some cash spare i would upgrade lake to a waters/grimes type priced player or downgrade to a rook and make an upgrade elsewhere (if you can find enough solid rook picks in def named for a game round 1). That is the issue

[nostradamus]

l had to rate it as solid.....its too similar to mine not to  ::)