Sloane v Pendles

[Triton121]

what ya reckon?

sloane might only be 15 ppg behind pendles on avg??

[T Dog]

Pendles all day long for me

[Holz]

the only reason i would conisder sloane over pendles is due to the bye round. Simply pendles probabaly will be a top 6 players sloane wont

[Doyle]

Sloane isn't a worthy comparison with Pendlebury. It's like comparing an average Holden to a HSV.

Pendlebury: 120+ avg IMO
Sloane: 95-100+ avg IMO

That being said, you could have both, Pendlebury as the outright gun and Sloane as the mid-pricer-turned-premium

[Ziplock]

... in DT?

swan is the only player in DT to have EVER averaged over 120 ppg. Personally I can't see him dropping his possession rate, so that would mean pendles stepping up into the same range. While feasible, it's unlikely. If it happens, lock the pies in for a premiership- it might not seem like much, but at that level of competence, playing professionally, it's a substantial gap.

[TheMailman]

With Sloane you're still looking at a lot of 70s 80s and 90s whereas Pendlebury is basically 100< every week

[Holz]

... in DT?

swan is the only player in DT to have EVER averaged over 120 ppg. Personally I can't see him dropping his possession rate, so that would mean pendles stepping up into the same range. While feasible, it's unlikely. If it happens, lock the pies in for a premiership- it might not seem like much, but at that level of competence, playing professionally, it's a substantial gap.

im now thinking swan will go down abit, with guys like sidebottom and thomas always improving let alone pendles, there is only so much ball a team can have and if it were me i would rather have the ball in pendles hands than swans. I just dropped swan for pendles that was ahrd chocie but pendles for sloane is not

[yorgis]

U SERIOUS ????

[Holz]

U SERIOUS ????

i am serious for me pendles is the better player and collingwood should give him the ball more, swanny is still a superstar but i think pendles could overtake him in DT this year.

[Ziplock]

in the OP it really depends on whether or not you can make do with the 150k.

[Justin Bieber]

Pendles all day long.

[me]

Sloane isn't a worth even comparison with Pendlebury.

this is the correct response to the thread

[Holz]

Sloane isn't a worth even comparison with Pendlebury.

this is the correct response to the thread

i think the poll is showing that, would suck though is sloane comes out and does a rockliff though