breakout candidate vs. proven star

Started by Jay, March 13, 2012, 05:52:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Brent Harvey or Patrick Dangerfield?

boomer
16 (40%)
danger
24 (60%)

Total Members Voted: 3

Jay

the aging but GUN boomer harvey or the up-and-coming youngster pattyD? Who should it be danger or boomer?

Jay

wow the poll is close! Remember...im looking for who will have scored the most points by seasons end. Not the better average or the biggest price riser...

Bosh

Boomer will still score the most out of the two if price doesn't come into it.

Jay

yeah that is what I was thinking...people are so sure that danger will have a breakout year! Is it possible that if danger does play through the mids and is scoring tons consistently...he could be say my first upgrade target?

Bosh

Well no, I dont think so. It's better to start with him because if he is pumping out consistent 100's you save yourself a trade. Of course if he isn't (he should still be averaging 85-90) which isn't too bad.

Jay

Quote from: Bosh on March 13, 2012, 07:49:24 PM
Well no, I dont think so. It's better to start with him becauseif he is pumping out consistent 100's you save yourself a trade. Of course if he isn't (he should still be averaging 85-90) which isn't too bad.
so you think get danger or boomer? lol

MC

Boomer is almost certain to drop some points from his average, while Dangermouse is looking set to go the other way. At the end of the day, either will be a solid F5 by season's end so pick the one YOU think will do better. It's your team :)

Jay

Quote from: MC on March 13, 2012, 10:12:09 PM
Boomer is almost certain to drop some points from his average, while Dangermouse is looking set to go the other way. At the end of the day, either will be a solid F5 by season's end so pick the one YOU think will do better. It's your team :)
sure is my team!!!!! ;)

Im just so unsure though! Im leaning towards harvey scoring more but danger's potential is unbelievable!!!

tor01doc

Hey J,

Got the dolphin too?

If so, then maybe Boomer for you.

I'm on Danger myself unless I go troppo and do the sacrificial R13 bye team I've been toying with.

Jay

Quote from: tor01doc on March 13, 2012, 10:18:13 PM
Hey J,

Got the dolphin too?

If so, then maybe Boomer for you.

I'm on Danger myself unless I go troppo and do the sacrificial R13 bye team I've been toying with.
yeah porps and kerridge are also in my fwds...kerridge can be switched into mids for devon smith though...

MontyJnr

I can't take Dangerfield seriously as a pick to be honest.

Jay

ehh...everyones allowed an opinion! Danger is up by 7 in the poll by the way...

The Supercoach

Quote from: MC on March 13, 2012, 10:12:09 PM
Boomer is almost certain to drop some points from his average, while Dangermouse is looking set to go the other way. At the end of the day, either will be a solid F5 by season's end so pick the one YOU think will do better. It's your team :)

Y? He is ageing but nothing shows that hes stopping. Boomer will probs average more then dangers but the price is a MASSIVE factor and thats y i have danger

MC

He's turning 34 this year and will spend more time in the forward line imo. Can you honestly see him IMPROVING?

Jay

well his team will improve...normally resulting in better scores