birchall vs. bock vs. lids vs. scotland vs. fisher vs. newman

Started by Jay, March 13, 2012, 05:46:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which defender!

Birchall
11 (25.6%)
Bock
6 (14%)
Deledio
17 (39.5%)
Scotland
7 (16.3%)
Fisher
2 (4.7%)
Newman
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jay

ive already got goddard, shaw and broughton in my backs...so i need one more! The options are listed in the poll! Please help :)

Jroo

Deledio is probably the best opition but Birchall could be a very good unique pick. Thanks

Jay


tor01doc


Jay


BigBob


Jay

Quote from: BigBob on March 13, 2012, 09:46:09 PM
hamie=risk 4 lids
this ^^^ and his tough draw are the only reasons why he isnt a lock in every team :D

MontyJnr

If lids is looking shaky, i'm swapping him to scotland

Jay


Jay

oops...had forgot newman? anyone got any thoughts on him...

burner11

I've got Newman instead of Deledio atm due to hammy issues, will upgrade to Deledio after the bye if he's doing alright

Jay

yeah it's a good idea...but will newman score more than say scotland/birchall?

burner11

Newman averaged 98, Scotland 105 and Birchall 94 last year ;-)

Bosh

Quote from: burner11 on March 15, 2012, 09:31:07 AM
Newman averaged 98, Scotland 105 and Birchall 94 last year ;-)

Although, the match where Newman got injured he went off in the 2nd qtr I think and only scored 30 or something so that affects his averages. So around 101 avg