Broughton vs Birchall

[sammy_boy]

Who is better. help?

[MLS]

I think Birchall is the safer option, however 'if' Broughton plays midfield he has the bigger upside.

[spasticnut]

Broughton mate, and he will get more of a run in the midfield this season which will make him score better than last year aswell

[demon_spud]

Was reading on the DT talk site, the Lyons was playing Broughton everywhere, started in the forwards, then moved to the mids, then was tagging towards the end.  Seems to be the utility man like Bartel, smash it one week, spud it the next. Hop on and enjoy the ride.

[MontyJnr]

Was reading on the DT talk site, the Lyons was playing Broughton everywhere, started in the forwards, then moved to the mids, then was tagging towards the end.  Seems to be the utility man like Bartel, smash it one week, spud it the next. Hop on and enjoy the ride.

Or utility man like goddard, and just dominate every week :)

[demon_spud]

Was reading on the DT talk site, the Lyons was playing Broughton everywhere, started in the forwards, then moved to the mids, then was tagging towards the end.  Seems to be the utility man like Bartel, smash it one week, spud it the next. Hop on and enjoy the ride.

Or utility man like goddard, and just dominate every week :)

yeah either way, goddard is falling though.

[MC]

Falling where? He had a 'terrible' year last year and still averaged 107... The best defender by a country mile. Capable of a 130+ average, which not many players are capable of, and St Kilda should pick up a few extra wins this year with the return of Hayes and NRoo (to form) etc.

[Vicious Sandwhich Attack]

This is also one of my biggest conundrums. I have swapped these two around at least 2 dozen times.. Just can't seperate them for now, and can't assist you on this one   :o