Jobe & Scotland or Pendles & Malceski

[Zabs]

Which combo guys

[quinny88]

Jobe and scotland for mine.
Pendles will drop in price eventually and malceski is a big gamble.
Jobe is a gamble aswell but we know he will score 105+ if he stays injury free

[fever]

jobe/scotland

[JamSainter]

Pendles/Malceski.
Pendles will be top 2 mids this uear, Watson won't be top 10.
Malceski's had a ripper preseason and has value to gain.

[Zabs]

Hmm it's a tough one, Im leaning towards jobe, coz Essendon has easy draw and not many essedndon players will steal points. Scotland should outscore ceski.

[BlackMamba]

Too much risk in Malceski IMO. Scotland and Watson should get you at least 100-110 each week. The question is whether Jobe is gonna be a top 6 midfielder this year.

[enzedder]

Pendles/Malceski.
Pendles will be top 2 mids this uear, Watson won't be top 10.
Malceski's had a ripper preseason and has value to gain.

Agree with all of this.

[nathan11]

if you take out jobe's injuries he avg about 120 last year 131 on friday night  scotland avg 105 last year  looks by far the best choice

[upthemaidens]

isnt malceski just an injury waiting to happen?
  i like the third option  pendles,scotland  haha  i guess u cant afford that

[coolfugitiv0]

Pendles/Malceski.
Pendles will be top 2 mids this uear, Watson won't be top 10.
Malceski's had a ripper preseason and has value to gain.

Agree with all of this.

Before he got injured, Watson was averaging over 120.
How many mids can you name that beat that? I can name only 3. Won't be top ten? Ha.

Malceski may have value to gain, but he won't be a keeper. Scotland will. Save a trade.

Watson/Scotland 100%

[upthemaidens]

i know this is not a jobe thread,but i would like to add...
jobe has NEVER played every game of a season and his highest average ever is 106, at the age of 27? i cant imagine he is going to suddenly play every game this year and average 115+,,
  so its fair to say that he will not be in the top 10 point scorers in the mid-field this year...