Master Q's Analyser

[Master Q]

Cristensen vs Porps.

I think Christensen has more potential but I think as Mid-Pricers you want to make money off them and upgrade. Porps is safer IMO so I'd go him.

[Colliwobblers]

1. Thoughts on Myers,Conca,Hargrave,Lake,Howard options for a mid priced defender or two?

2. Tom Lynch ? Smokie breakout candidate after moving for the Saints to the Crows has impressed in NAB CUP with a 70 backed up by another 70 in both full games - thoughts on him?

3. Your thoughts on Ruck set-up - 2+2 or 1+3 GUN/ROOKS

4. Thoughts on minimum cash in bank to keep for start of round 1?

5. Thoughts on Gray-Sidebottom-Zaka-Adams-Didak-Harvey-Dangerfield-Christensen, of that sub-$450 FWD/MID group ?

6. Further to the last, is Patty D finally going to breakout...?

Feel free to answer as you get time one at a time. But as a relitively new player these I feel are questions wiht answers from an experienced coach that would be very valuable/

[bomberboy0618]

Do you know who will be the next Relton Roberts?

Jobe Watson. You heard it here.

PS: Please remember that this is my thread and I will do the answering!  :) If you want to have a discussion on a player, make a thread!

Walked into that didn't I.

[Master Q]

1. Thoughts on Myers,Conca,Hargrave,Lake,Howard options for a mid priced defender or two?

2. Tom Lynch ? Smokie breakout candidate after moving for the Saints to the Crows has impressed in NAB CUP with a 70 backed up by another 70 in both full games - thoughts on him?

3. Your thoughts on Ruck set-up - 2+2 or 1+3 GUN/ROOKS

4. Thoughts on minimum cash in bank to keep for start of round 1?

5. Thoughts on Gray-Sidebottom-Zaka-Adams-Didak-Harvey-Dangerfield-Christensen, of that sub-$450 FWD/MID group ?

6. Further to the last, is Patty D finally going to breakout...?

Feel free to answer as you get time one at a time. But as a relitively new player these I feel are questions wiht answers from an experienced coach that would be very valuable/

1. I've given thoughts on most of these players on Page 2 and 5 or 6 but I'll just summarise them again.

Generally I stay away from Mid-Pricers unless they will obviously make money.

Myers - Wouldn't consider. Never seen much him and isn't really a key member of the Bombers backline.

Conca - I see something in him, potential.

Hargrave - Big reason to look at him considering his previous few seasons but I'm not sure it's worth the risk TBH.

Lake - Exact same at Hargrave. Less risky though.

Howard - Stay away.

2. Porps? Has some competition at the Crows as well.

3. 2+2. Much much better but 1-3 is workable.

4. Depends on your team. If it's a safe team with mostly Gun/Rookies then you don't need much. If it's a more risky team with a lot of Rookies or is a bit unbalanced I'd try have AT LEAST 15k.

5.

Gray - Eh. Undecided TBH.

Sidebottom - Like him. Have him.

Zaha - You'll get what you pay for. Prefer Sidebum.

Adams - Has potential IMO. Haven't heard much on him though.

Didak - Too risky for me...

Harvey - Old.

Dangerfield - Has Potential. I see something in him. Mid-Pricer though, is it worth it?

Christensen - Has Potential with a big roof. Think their are better options TBH...

7. Sorry, Patty D? Who is he  :-[

[Master Q]

Do you know who will be the next Relton Roberts?

Jobe Watson. You heard it here.

PS: Please remember that this is my thread and I will do the answering!  :) If you want to have a discussion on a player, make a thread!

Walked into that didn't I.

Which one?

If you are talking about Jobe, yeh, you did  ;)

If you are talking about the second one, that wan't aimed at you...

[Colliwobblers]

patty d = dangerfield

thanks for the answers Q

[Master Q]

patty d = dangerfield

thanks for the answers Q

Ah  :P I gave my opinion anyway  ;D

[Master Q]

Anymore questions?

[mezzoculo]

What... is the air-speed velocity of an unladen swallow?  ;D

[Capper]

Sandilands or Big boy mcevoy??

[Jukes]

Sandilands or Big boy mcevoy??

I'd go Benny Mac from those, prefer Mummy and Berger over both of them though.

[Master Q]

Sandilands or Big boy mcevoy??

Neither. Mummy or Burger but if you had to choose McEvoy.

Jukes:

PS: Please remember that this is my thread and I will do the answering!  :)  If you want to have a discussion on a player, make a thread!

[mezzoculo]

Jukes:
PS: Please remember that this is my thread and I will do the answering!  :)  If you want to have a discussion on a player, make a thread!

I would embed this if I knew how...
http://images.cheezburger.com/completestore/2011/4/30/76ee5da5-09e2-4790-900d-c93f71802ec3.jpg

[Master Q]

Highlight and click the photo frame  ;)

[Justin Bieber]

I cbf reading, but Gia? Thoughts..