Suckling v Birchall v Broughton

[Davoo]

theyre all in my team at the moment but who would you get rid of to free some cash??

[Torpedo10]

Broughton is thr most risky so dump him for some1 safer(Heppell,Hanley etc.) OR go right down to Waters or Grimes to get some more cash but they are riskier.

[mezzoculo]

Broughton is thr most risky so dump him for some1 safer(Heppell,Hanley etc.) OR go right down to Waters or Grimes to get some more cash but they are riskier.

Broughton has been one of the biggest DT rollercoaster rides and so far this pre-season this doesn't seem to have changed (even with a new coach).

[Windigo]

Birchall for safety.

Suckling for massive scores and some ordinary ones.

Broughton.....Who knows.  :P

[JamSainter]

Birchall for safety.

Suckling for massive scores and some ordinary ones.

Broughton.....Who knows.  :P

+1, good summary! :)

[Master Q]

Broughton! Pretty easy...

[Justin Bieber]

Do you even want to know my opinion? haha

[Davoo]

i wanted to downgrade one of them like to a rookie just to improve other areas, so i went broughton > smedts and jobe watson > boyd and now i have like 265k in bank and dont know where to improve! its not enough to upgrade giles to a gun ruck (besides hmac) and its not enough to have another premo mid so the option is upgrading a rookie in one of the areas to a mid-pricer, any thoughts on good mid-priceers around? the only 2 i have are hargrave and danger already. dont know where to spend money!!

[mezzoculo]

i wanted to downgrade one of them like to a rookie just to improve other areas, so i went broughton > smedts and jobe watson > boyd and now i have like 265k in bank and dont know where to improve! its not enough to upgrade giles to a gun ruck (besides hmac) and its not enough to have another premo mid so the option is upgrading a rookie in one of the areas to a mid-pricer, any thoughts on good mid-priceers around? the only 2 i have are hargrave and danger already. dont know where to spend money!!

My 2 cents on the rucks (well, for the next few days anway) is that one IVAN MARIC could be a good chocie for the R2 position for those people not 100% sold on Giles. He looks to be the primary Richmond ruck, he's cheaper than HMac, is injury-free and has the Round 13 bye (giving you plenty of upgrade options). Perhaps that could be a worthy investment for your extra cash?

[Swallow12]

Suckling may play more mid this year, should increase regardless