the 5th MID position !!

Started by essendon2, March 12, 2012, 10:39:41 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

which option?

Chris Masten
John McCarthy
Rookie + 150k (let me know what you'd do with the $$$)
Other (please comment)

Justin Bieber

Yeah not sure. I would have to drop a back to get him.... so probs not worth it  :-\

essendon2

Quote from: whatlez on March 12, 2012, 02:07:56 PM
Yeah not sure. I would have to drop a back to get him.... so probs not worth it  :-\
DEF's are most inconsistent scorers... last season, you definitely couldn't back your 'backs' to get you 90+ , but your MIDS, you can guarantee that they'll get you 100+ - Masten also has a ceiling of 141. and if it was a full game on the weekend, Masten was looking at 130+

Justin Bieber

I have said that Forwards are more the key. There are 5 good backs this year and you pick 4 of them.

essendon2

I've got Shaw, Deledio, Birchall, Waters, Hargrave, Bower, Ellis

Justin Bieber

Yeah I would Goddard instead of Waters. And Clarke instead of Bower.

essendon2

Quote from: whatlez on March 12, 2012, 03:09:14 PM
Yeah I would Goddard instead of Waters. And Clarke instead of Bower.
But I'd rather Waters + Masten than Goddard + Rookie!!  :P