2nd ruck

[nicko11]

Redden will be a prolific scorer when he plays, but i rate Giles much higher, interested to hear thoughts

[elephants]

I would choose them as your second ruck based on who they are playing and what the opposing teams ruck department is like. Conditions would also need to come into consideration but I see both averaging mid 70's.

[Football Factory]

+ 1

[Dudge]

As a Power supporter, i would say Giles, simply because of j/s, not necessarly form

[Dudge]

May i say, i voted Redden (touch of bias :))

[Capper]

i have them both on my bench, dont trust them yet to start