Time to complete the team.. where to start?

[charliesheen]

Think this is a no brainer

K.Jack > M.Murphy

Points lost outweighs minor cash generation of K.Jack.

[kma07]

That was my first thought but wasnt sure if i should burn a trade, but points do outweigh the cash

[charliesheen]

As long as trade has good logic behind it, you shouldn't fear burning trades ;)  Remain proactive.  Team is looking solid, good luck in your leagues.

[kma07]

Summary:
Round 4 score- 2181
Overall ranking- 19,820 from 44,399
Won all my h2h leagues

Pretty happy considering all the injuries. 

Made 2 trades:
Mumford -> H.Macintosh
Ledger -> C.Pearce
Decided to hold on to Jack mainly due to the injuries and I was rewarded with a ton.

Current side::

DEF:
Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Malceski, M.Clarke,T.Bugg (Ellis, Baguely)

MID:
Ablett, A.Swallow, Rockliff, K.Jack, Magner, Fyfe (T.Greene, D.Shiel)

RUCK:
McIntosh, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FWD:
Buddy, Pearce, D.Martin, Porplyzia, D.Smith, A.Kennedy, Goodes (Smedts, A.Hall)


Birchall and Goodes will come back in,

So this weeks question is whether it's time for Fyfe to go or wait until the cows fatten up a bit more?


I want to bring in M.Murphy, J.Selwood and Pendlebury in the coming weeks


$220,000 left

20 Trades remaining

[charliesheen]

Those are extremely high risk high reward trades.  You took 2 mid pricers (who may or may not become keepers) for 2 premiums.  Not sure I would have done them myself.  If Fyfe named on Friday, you simply have to keep him.

I would consider moving out Baguely for Treloar using Smedts again.  K.Jack > Pendlebury in a few weeks looking good.  Saying that Pendlebury has a ridiculous ANZAC day record, so if he goes big, its going to hurt.

[kma07]

Yeh I was originally going to trade out Jack -> Murphy until all the injuries, thought I'd take a punt on those 2 and so far it's paid off...

Read somewhere Fyfe has trained today well and had no problems taking overhead marks.. happy to keep him


Pendlebury is a big game player, but I will wait a week or so for him.

[charliesheen]

Wouldn't say its paid off yet.  Long season :D  But looks good so far.  Definitely take Treloar this week.

[kma07]

Well a week is a hell of a long time in football hey..

Summary:
Round 5 score- 1816
Overall ranking- 38301 from 19820
Lost all my h2h leagues

Dismal week once again leaving me 1-2 in my h2h leagues

Trades in: Barlow
Trades out: Fyfe

Current side::

DEF:
Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Malceski, M.Clarke,T.Bugg (Ellis, Baguely)

MID:
Ablett, A.Swallow, Rockliff, Barlow, K.Jack, Magner (T.Greene, D.Shiel)

RUCK:
McIntosh, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FWD:
Buddy, Pearce, D.Martin, Porplyzia, D.Smith, A.Kennedy, Goodes (Smedts, A.Hall)

$303,800 left
19 Trades remaining

Missed out on trading out Baguely for Treloar due to the partial lockout doh!
I decided on bringing Barlow for Fyfe.  Pretty sideways but I wanted to bank the money and don't have faith in Fyfe's shoulder yet.

Shall I bring in Pendlebury for Jack, or are there other trades I should do?

Has D.Smith run his course?

[GoldDigger]

2 questions, 2 answers .. no x 2.

[kma07]

Summary:
Round 6 score- 2107
Overall ranking- 38289
won all my h2h leagues

2-2 in my main league

Trades in: Pendlebury
Trades out: K.Jack

Current side::

DEF:
Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Malceski, M.Clarke,T.Bugg (Ellis, Baguely)

MID:
Ablett, A.Swallow, Rockliff, Barlow, Pendlebury, Magner (T.Greene, D.Shiel)

RUCK:
McIntosh, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FWD:
Buddy, Pearce, D.Martin, Porplyzia, D.Smith, A.Kennedy, Goodes (Smedts, A.Hall)

$131,700 left
18 Trades remaining


Question for this week is do I do:

A.Kennedy/A.Hall -> T.Adams
Magner -> Horsely

Which would leave me with $376,000 plus Goodes to trade out next week

Or should I save the trades and do only A.Kennedy/A.Hall -> T.Adams

[Ringo]

Depends oh how much to cash in on these two.  In your situation there is not a lot of need. Would only look at kennedy to Adams but you are trading one Round 11 bye player for another so need to factor that in.
I would be tempted to go Goodes to Beams this week though has hit form and price is just starting to rise.  More than likely will adopt the Ball role so plenty of points there at a cheap price. 

[kma07]

Summary:
Round 7 score- 2223
Overall ranking- 41006
won all my h2h leagues

3-2 in my main league sitting 7th

Trades in: d.Beams, a.Hall
Trades out: a.Goodes, t.Adams
Current side::

DEF:
Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Malceski, M.Clarke,T.Bugg (Ellis, Baguely)

MID:
Ablett, A.Swallow, Rockliff, Barlow, Pendlebury, Magner (T.Greene, D.Shiel)

RUCK:
McIntosh, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FWD:
Buddy, Pearce, D.Martin, Porplyzia, D.Smith, A.Kennedy, D.Beams(Smedts, T.Adams)

$213,600 left
16 Trades remaining


Still waiting to see if Hanley and Hamish will miss..

However I have an easy h2h matchup which I should win, so I'm thinking
About saving trades.. Or is there any trades I should/need to do this week?
I'm only averaging 2090 per round and need to get it up around 2400 to keep up with the leaders

[Ringo]

No need to trade unless H Mac is out for a period of time.  You may want to look at something in your rucks as both Hmac and Giles have Round 11 bye and Reddan and Stephenson not playing possibility of 2 donuts in ruck. Suggestion to help Porps to Roughhead when he has maxed out and Reddan to Pattinson if he does not get games.  That way you can move Roughy in and out of Rucks as required.

[kma07]

Thanks Ringo

Any news yet on Hanley?

[Ringo]

Thanks Ringo

Any news yet on Hanley?

Listed as Test - Posted Brisbanes injury List on the Brisbane Board.