Top 5 Rookie price defenders for ROUND 1

[arzbar96]

In terms of JS and points potential.

[arzbar96]

Also, what do you guys think, will Bugg and Darley be named together each week? Hopefully the will because I can't split them..

[owenbond007]

missing a few guys such as yagmoor.

[LEV]

Miles ?
Clifton ?
Smith ?
Hampton ?
Walsh ?

[BGK]

Miles ?
Clifton ?
Smith ?
Hampton ?
Walsh ?

Any of those guys Defenders?

[Capper]

In terms of JS its the GWS and GC players, points are the other teams

[Dudge]

Miles ?
Clifton ?
Smith ?
Hampton ?
Walsh ?

Any of those guys Defenders?

I think not  :)

[LEV]

ahh ok, sorry about that, i thought you meant rookies in general. I should learn to read. Soz again !

[LEV]

BTW, if i had to pick 5, i would run with Bugg, Darley, Morris, Ellis, Clarke.  Think Mohr would be up there for job security also.

[Capper]

Clarke has decent JS but needs to get on the ground first to cement his spot, may miss out on points due to pies mids
Hunt   will play more time in mids and has great JS, points arent great though and has brain fades
Bugg   good js but will be a lock down player at the back
Darley good JS but how will GWS backs go on points??
Bower should play R1 and for a decent return
Smedts good JS but may become a tagger and his points may drop
Wilkes will play the role of Zac dawson last year, low points
Mohr   see darley/Bugg
Spurr needs to be elevated, low points, low JS
Ellis better option than Morris and Webberley, good propect
Morris    better than Weeberly
Golds see darley/Bugg

[unceramonius]

^^^^^^^^^^^ smedts good job security?

he has NONE.   probs wont even play round one.   there is a wealth of young cats vying for spots.

[TheMailman]

^^^^^^^^^^^ smedts good job security?

he has NONE.   probs wont even play round one.   there is a wealth of young cats vying for spots.

With several Cats retiring and Smedts has been talked up by the Geelong staff a fair amount I'd expect his Job secruity to be reasonable. Doubt he plays all 22 games though

[Jukes]

Love have the top 5 options in the poll :P Bugg, Darley, Smedts, Ellis and Clarke.

[Torpedo10]

Love have the top 5 options in the poll :P Bugg, Darley, Smedts, Ellis and Clarke.

I have these guys and I think they are the best options.

[owenbond007]

I got 4 of em. No smedts for me though. Think hell spend most the first half of the year in the vfl. Even if he doesnt his scoring potential hasnt looked great.