Broughton Vs Birchall Vs Adcock

[mudgee]

Hey guys - I need some help with my D4 pick. I currently have Birchall but now I am thinking Adcock could be a big improver this year, plus he has a round 11 bye.
Ive got Goddard, Lids, H Shaw, Insert D4 here, Eski, Davis, Hargrave (Darley & Morris on the pine) in my other possies... Thoughts??

[enzedder]

Hey guys - I need some help with my D4 pick. I currently have Birchall but now I am thinking Adcock could be a big improver this year, plus he has a round 11 bye.
Ive got Goddard, Lids, H Shaw, Insert D4 here, Eski, Davis, Hargrave (Darley & Morris on the pine) in my other possies... Thoughts??

Broughton for mine but any of those 3 should serve you well I think. Not much in it.

[mudgee]

Broughton pulling ahead... Makes my decision even tougher!! (=P)

[jasonweare]

Have all 3 in my team ATM.

[Ringo]

I have both Birchall and Adcock in my team at the moment.  Waiting on Broughton to see how is used in the comp.

[no eye deer]

Got all three as well. Who knows what role Broughton will play though. So many good backs for Freo. Tempted to just get Subin and save cash.