Getting Close to finished team, rate mine and I'll rate yours ;)

[BlueMad]

Here is my updated team, pretty happy with it just a few 50/50's

DEF: Goddard, H.Shaw, Newman, Yarran, Hargrave, Ellis, Bugg
Darley, Blee

MID: Ablett, Swan, Priddis, McCarthy, Clifton, C.Smith
Miles, Magner

RUCK: Mumford, McEvoy
Giles, Redden

FWD: Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Goodes/Stevie J???, Porplyzia, D.Smith, Cameron
Couch, Smedts

Still got $43k in the bank

Thoughts would be really appreciated and if you ask I can rate your team aswell  ;)

[felsty]

B: nice and settled. not a fan of yarran. once prices start getting that low there is a real lack of consistency, maybe apart from heppell..
M: solid line again. clifton hasnt shown much so maybe swap him
R: set and forget
F: not a fan of cloke. goes missing some games but the other picks are all great. Smedts JS isnt great

i would upgrade yarran while youre at it too and get in goodes or fyfe for cloke
all in all a strong side 8.75/10
rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50385.0.html

[BlueMad]

Who would you recommend instead of Yarran? Adcock, Hanley, Broughton??? and no problem I'll check yours out

[corzer03]

i reckon adock or broughton instead of yarran but apart from that a solid side 9/10.

could you have a look at mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50333.0.html

[JamSainter]

... Yeah coz Adcock & Broughton are a picture of consistency...
Stick with Yarran if that's what you see best (imo he is a good pick).
And Clifton hasn't shown much??? What? Look at the stats last night, keep him!!!!
Overall a nice sound team 9/10

[BlueMad]

... Yeah coz Adcock & Broughton are a picture of consistency...
Stick with Yarran if that's what you see best (imo he is a good pick).
And Clifton hasn't shown much??? What? Look at the stats last night, keep him!!!!
Overall a nice sound team 9/10

Cheers, I rate Yazz pretty high so probs going to keep him.

Clifton looks solid and more experienced then some of the young ones in the Giants squad, so will be certain of games and I know he can score well. He did win theVFL  B and F

[JamesHarden13]

DEF: Goddard, H.Shaw, Newman, Yarran, Hargrave, Ellis, Bugg
Darley, Blee
MID: Ablett, Swan, Priddis, Coniglio, Clifton, C.Smith
Miles, Magner
RUCK: Mumford, McEvoy
Giles, Redden
FWD: Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Cloke, Porplyzia, D.Smith, Smedts
Rowe, Hall

Def- good backline, kind of unique pick in yarran definitely will pay off, cant fault that area of your team.
mids- three gun premos, great. three rookies, very likely to get games too. i would use that cash to go coniglio to mccarthy too, trying to get him into my team as well! keep clifton as he is more mature and stronger then the younger lads.
rucks- cant fault, perfect!
forwards- would have a great forward line without cloke and maybe getting goodes instead as cloke is a key forward and is always fading out of games at times.
overall 8.5/10, nice team!

[BlueMad]

Updated team with everyones thoughts, cheers guys.

If you need me to rate your team just ask and I'll be happy to :)

[salce]

thanks for rating my team mate!

backs - liking the yarran pick. very unique and might pay off for you.
mids - good pick with priddis, havent seen him in many teams
rucks - loving it
fwds - i agree that cloke shouldn't be in your team. maybe look at either goodes or fyfe.

overall 8.5/10

[BlueMad]

Whats everyones thoughts go with Goodes, or Stevie J is another good pick? Had him in my team ever since I started SC.

the other thought is going a Leigh Adams/Zacka/Gray. And gain some cash?

[JamSainter]

Goodes is a superstar! Will average 105+ again this year.

[CFA]

yarran +1
really like the McCarthy pick (just cant fit him into my side)
Goodes for sure

overall very solid side and would change must but like always see the rookies for rd1 i guess......

8/10