gone a little bit different. thoughts? r8 4 r8

[gotheroos!]

hey guys, i've made many standard drafts, but have gone for a little uniqueness. thoughts? just a trial. will rate urs too.

goddard scotland broughton adcock malceski hargrave ellis (tomilson darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson stevens kerridge (magner gibson)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin fyfe dangerfield sidebottom porplyzia d.smith pfeiffer (smedts weedon)

thoughts? $130k spare, what to do?

explanation:
defence is strong. malceski and hargrave are gambles, but both are proven guns. malceski has good fixtures.
mids: 4 premiums. watson is an unique pick. bombers have good fixtures.
rucks: only one gun, but redden seems a good player
fwds: weakest link. not getting goodes as everyone has him and i reckon he might be a bit slow to begin and can be bought later. will also wait on martin til he drops in price. franklin and fyfe are guns. dangerfield / sidebottom / porpus seem good.
                 

[Babylove]

Your back's are pretty strong.  Adcock is a unique pick.  Your mids are strong too.  Keep an eye out for the prognosis on Magner's injury.  Your rucks are risky.  Stephenson doesn't look like he's going to get decent SC scores and we haven't seen Giles play a full game with Brogan in the team, so we don't know if/how Sheedy will use them and how it will effect Giles Scores.

Your forwards are not bad, though a little risky.  I like the Dangerfield/Sidebottom/Porplyzia combination but not you are relying on at least one of them breaking out to become a premium.

If you could please have a look at my team it would be appreciated.  http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50303.0.html

[felsty]

B: too much risk, id pick one of eski and hargrave, eski for my liking.. also have fun riding the broughton roller coaster!
M: watson too injury prone for my liking.. get montagna at that price, proven sc scorer and should be better for having hayes back in the side
R: average. how many games is mumford going to play? as soon as he gets suspended or injured there goes your rucks. redden, giles and stephenson all dont look like being no.1 rucks when season starts
F: thin. relying on 2 brea out seasons too.. as much as stuff is said about martin the guy has been killing it this preseason.. mad not to get him in!

dg hargrave and use the money in your rucks. if you havent seen mcintosh has been killing it!

[gotheroos!]

thx guys. all valid points. i'll wait til next week and make a decision.

[CFA]

cant really complain about ur side mate... all across the side is strong, however i would try work something to make the ruck combo a bit stronger... let me know what u do or think?