Rate my team - something a little different

[doogz]

Thanks Johnny for the review.  I have changed the team a fair bit.  However, I had to make the fwd line much weaker though in doing it.  It is the standard Guns/Rooks structure with 14 premiums, 16 Rooks no midpricers.  I can downgrade the rucks, but I want my rucks to be set and forget.  Anyhow, this it the new line.  Pretty different than before:

B: Goddard, Deledio, shaw, Birchall, Adcock, Ellis, smedts (Bugg, Darley)
M: Ablett, Murphy, Selwood, Hogan, K Stevens, Miles, (L Brown, Magner - will change him out)
R: Cox, Mumford (Giles, Stephensen)
F: Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, N Riewoldt, D Smith, Pfeiffer, Cameron, (Hall, Couch)

I do want to put in Dangerfield and/or porpz.  Here is another take on the team but with these guys included.  It has made me take some risks though, similar to the first.  Please rate this compared to the one above.  Thanks

D: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Birchall, Adcock, Lake, Ellis (Darley, Brown)
M: Ablett, Murphy, Selwood, Pfeiffer, Treleor, Miles, (Gibson, Magner - will change him out)
R: Cox, McEvoy (Giles, Stepehensen)
F: Goodes, Fyfe, N Riewoldt, Dangerfield, Porpz, Cameron, Hampton (hall, couch)

8K Left

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: First you have too much depth here Adcock would be better of at B5 so to save a donut and money  you should downgrade fisher to a Rookie
Mids: Very Weak Need 3 premiums here you only one you will quickly fall behind the leaders. with this line up.Seems that Magner has a Broken Finger and in doubt for Round 1.
Rucks: Strong Rucks can't get any better.
Fwds: One of the first teams that Dosen't have Buddy instead going for Rioli.Once again your forward line has good depth.

Overall this team has big Problems in the Midfield suggest you downgrade a backman and a forward and upgrade 2 rookiese mids to premiums. i give you a 6/10

[doogz]

edited

[doogz]

Anymore reviews  ;D

[tor01doc]

Which team is the real one?

Happy to give my honest free (you get what you pay for) opinion.

[Ringo]

While strengthening Defence you weakened your forwards.  I would have kept Bugg instead of Lake and used money to upgrade N Roo to Franklin or Martin. May also have enough to go Murphy to Swan.
So changes to Team B Lake >Bugg; N Roo > Franklin/Martin/; Murphy > Swan making Team B very strong.

[doogz]

Thanks Ringo for your help.

My new team:

B: Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Birchall, Adcock, Ellis, Bugg (Darley, Morris)
M: Ablett, Priddis, Selwood, D Smith, Clifton, Miles (Kavanagh, Gibson)
R: Cox, McEvoy (Giles, Redden)
F: Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, N Riewoldt, Porpz, Pfeiffer, Cameron (Kerridge, Hall)

My main risks are N Roo and Porpz.  I plan to upgrade to buddy later in the year, as hawthorn have a very tough first half year draw. I don't want to run the risk of the 1-3 ruck as if either of the rucks flop, I am in big trouble.  I would love to have danger but I cant eat my cake and eat it too and I really like the backs this year out of the whole lineup.

Another point is I think Cox will play up forward a lot this year, not rucking as much as last year so this may have a negative impact.  If this is the way he plays on Saturday I plan on possibly downgrading cox and maybe upgrading porpz to danger.

[tor01doc]

Hey Buddy. Gotta get Buddy. Cheers, your Buddy.