Please Rate & i'll Rate yours :)

[GlassHarmonium]

Def: Goddard, Deledio, H.Shaw, B.Waters, R.Hargrave, Ellis, Bugg > J.Bouman, M.Talia

Mids: Ablett, Boyd, J.Selwood, Dangerfield, Coniglio, Magner > S.Gibson, D,Pfieffer

Ruc: Cox, Kruezer > Redden, Stephensen

Fwd: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, N.Riewolt, Porps, D.Smith, D.Zorco > T. Couch, G.Weedon

$79.500 in bank.

I realise Kruez is coming back from an ACL but i believe he is set for a big year!

Any feedback would be nice :)

[Babylove]

Overall good side.  I'm not a fan of Stephensen, based on his number in the NAB so far.  Think Giles might be a better bet.  Also think there are better options than N. Riewoldt for the price.  Also watch Zorko, I'm pretty sure he's had injury this preseason so make sure he is right for round one before picking him, & I'd pick him as a bench player given we haven't gotten a good form line on his ability to score SC/DT points.

[GlassHarmonium]

Do you think Chapman would be a better option than N.Riewolt??

[theflyinghawk]

DEF: Solid
MIDS: Would consider putting danger in the fwds and using the cash on someone else
RUCS: Good
FWD: Solid

Lots to work with keep playing around with it 7/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50264.0.html theres mine :)

[phiz3]

Backs: Look Solid
Mids: Maybe a little weak with Danger at M4 (Although he has been a monster in the NAB)
Rucks: Giles is probably a better option than stephenson
Fwds: if Nroo gets back into form then looking strong (be sure Zorko actually starts rd 1.

I'm thinking 7-8/10

I think you are one or two premos away from being done.

See what you think of mine.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50291.0.html

[phiz3]

definately like Chapman over NRoo if you have the cash for it   ;D

[Jay]

Backs: waters? ? ? ??? Plenty of other options mate. Bouman and Talia arent up to it, look elsewhere on the rookie front

Mid: yeah good enough, maybe swing danger into forwards tho?

Ruc: faultless

Fwd: i like very much :)

Overall 8/10...mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48411.75.html

[oconnell]

solid team only thing i can say is get rid of Nroo he is a major spud!!
8/10

plz rate mine :) http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50323.0.html

[Jay]

solid team only thing i can say is get rid of Nroo he is a major spud!!
8/10

plz rate mine :) http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50323.0.html

your joking??? Check this out:

N. Riewoldt- Past Supercoach Average Scores (footywire.com)
Year   Games   Average
2005   14            106.6
2006   22            117.2
2007   20            114.2
2008   21            114.0
2009   21            113.1
2010   11            108.9
2011   21             87.1

doesnt look like a spud to me mate??? Yes he had a rough year last year but with a new coach and hayes back to win more clearences, its gonna make roo's life a whole lot easier. So at that price along with his scoring capabilities, you could do a lot worse than picking nick riewoldt. Just my 2 cents :)

[GlassHarmonium]

Thanks for the feedback guys, i agree with you here Jayman besides his year last year he has been a SuperCoach must have. If he can get back to that form will be great.

Any suggestions who to get instead of Waters? Is S.Burgoyne worth a look?

[The Supercoach]

Not a bad looking team glass harmonium, but u have to do a bit of work to be dunadenn ::)

Waters is a risk and there is probably better options, if u have enough money maybe some1 like adcock, murphy or hurn

Midfield looks good but i would move dangers forward and get someone like sloane, gaff, ziebell, hayes

rucks look great although i would consider H mac over kru

forwards look good if porps and roo can get back to form you shoul be good

overall pretty good team 7.89/10

[Jay]

Thanks for the feedback guys, i agree with you here Jayman besides his year last year he has been a SuperCoach must have. If he can get back to that form will be great.

Any suggestions who to get instead of Waters? Is S.Burgoyne worth a look?

yes

[gotheroos!]

Def: Goddard, Deledio, H.Shaw, B.Waters, R.Hargrave, Ellis, Bugg > J.Bouman, M.Talia

Mids: Ablett, Boyd, J.Selwood, Dangerfield, Coniglio, Magner > S.Gibson, D,Pfieffer

Ruc: Cox, Kruezer > Redden, Stephensen

Fwd: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, N.Riewolt, Porps, D.Smith, D.Zorco > T. Couch, G.Weedon

$79.500 in bank.

I realise Kruez is coming back from an ACL but i believe he is set for a big year!

Any feedback would be nice :)

cheers for the help with my team!
defence: fine except for waters, who seems a gamble. hargrave is ok. but waters is risky with his poor discipline.
mids: fine, but better of getting dangerfield in fwds and getting another gun in mids instead (e.g. murphy)
rucks: fine. maybe hmac instead of kreuzer to save money
fwdS: fine
8/10

[Madmax75]

Very solid team well structured with only N Roo Waters and Hargrave being the weak spots. I think with Williams out Hargrave will get a lock down job and there are better options than Waters. N Roo doesn't have the support so will be double teamed a lot against the forward press etc .
Mine
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50330.0.html

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Backs look Ok concern could be with waters is he worth having at D4
Mids: Magner got subbed off early in todays game so wait to see that he is clear to play in Round 1. I also agree about Dangerfield he is better suited up forward. You are probably got him there so you can make use of the DPP. But the good thing is that you are strong enough in the midfield.
Rucks: Kreuzer is a Risky pick was rested from todays Nab Cup. Giles should be on your bench.
Fwds: Very Strong

Overall. You have enough talent in this team to keep you up there with leaders early on. i give this team an 8/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50052.0.html