rate for a rate?

[gotheroos!]

how's this team? $32k in the bank, rate/comment and i'll return the favour!

goddard scotland broughton heppell hargrave ellis webberley (darley smedts)
ablett murphy boyd selwood kerridge magner (gibson neale)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes fyfe sidebottom dangerfield d.smith tomilson (pfeiffer zorko)

thoughts? thx! :)

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Looks really good will webberley score better than a rookie.One of the few teams that dosen't have LIDS
Mids Very impressive midfield good selection of rookies.
Rucks: The first i have seen that has Redden as 2nd Ruck will he be first ruck at the power ahead of Lobbe.
Fwds: Fantastic forward line can't fault it there is certainly the high risk in Dangerfield but i think this is his year

Overall You have a strong line with the only weakness being the ruck. I give your team an 8/10 It has enough premiums to be competitive.Just need to watch Hargrave & Redden in the next NAB Cup games.

[yangers95]

Im liking the team mate, onyl problem is i dont think 1 premium 1 rookie ruck will work out too well when u could face some guy with say jacobs and big boy, might be down 60 something points in the ruck

backs: good - unsure on broughton but could kill it
mids: fairly standard, but still good
rucks: refer above
fwds: great strength here, good rookies too except i am not sold on pfeiffer, watch him and zorko may have injury issues

8.5/10, solid side

[gotheroos!]

goddard scotland broughton adcockhargrave ellis webberley (darley smedts)
ablett murphy watson selwood kerridge magner (gibson neale)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes fyfe sidebottom dangerfield d.smith tomilson (pfeiffer weedon)

A few changes, now got $45k in the bank? thoughts? thx! post ur urls and i'll return the favour :)

[Degsman]

goddard scotland broughton adcockhargrave ellis webberley (darley smedts)
ablett murphy watson selwood kerridge magner (gibson neale)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes fyfe sidebottom dangerfield d.smith tomilson (pfeiffer weedon)

A few changes, now got $45k in the bank? thoughts? thx! post ur urls and i'll return the favour :)

Backs: I like it!! if adcock gets up it looks to really good!! Just watch Hargrave....

Mids: Gun!

Rucks: If redden gets first ruck then this will be awesome!

Forwards: danger and sidebottom are looking to breakout this year.....I like it!!

Overall great side 9/10!!

[GlassHarmonium]

Awesome team, 9/10

Obviously 1 rookie ruckman on the ground is a risk, but if you are willing to take that risk all good

Not a fan of Broughton, prefer H.Shaw or S.Fisher, but other than that cant really fault your team

Good work

can you please rate mine http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50297.0.html

cheers

[phiz3]

Every year you have to have risks in you team to be successful, and the ones i can see of yours are:

Back: Broughton staying midfield
Mids: not got pendles or swan...
rucks: 3 rookies
Forwards: Hoping Sidey and Danger take a big step up this year.

All of those risks seem reasonable so good luck to you :)

8.5/10

Here's mine:
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50291.0.html

[Jay]

Backs: excellent...fairl unique as well :)

Mid: another faultless line...im liking it mate!

Ruc: pretty good condidering you only have 1 premium

Fwd: top line mate

Overall: 9/10 :) mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48411.75.html

[oconnell]

very solid side with great balance across the board 9/10 :)

plz rate mine http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50323.0.html

[gotheroos!]

thx guys, may have to pick new rookies now (magner and neale injured)

will get to rating urs soon :)

[Madmax75]

Looks like just about the right level of risk. I think you have to take a risk with two or three players and you have 5 so a bit too much for me. I would pick one of Heppel and Hargrave and also one of sidebum and Danger. Mine
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50330.0.html

[JamesHarden13]

backs - love the pick of adcock, reckon he will benefit with the return of drummond and merret, good backline.
mids - four good premos cant fault, rookies will obviously change so that doesnt matter.
rucks - not a real fan of the structure you have here, redden has showed a bit but will he score as much as the coxs, leuenbergers, mceveoys etc. but you picked rookies likely to play so good choices there.
forwards - can not fault your forwards, danger at f5 is a luxury!
i give this an 8/10 only because of your rucks mate

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50345.0.html
rate mine please mate, cheers!