Murphy and Gibbs

[Jukes]

Wouldn't go Murphy nor Gibbs, can't see enough upside in them to go with them over lads like Rocky, Selwood and STANTON!

[TheMailman]

Yeah Stanton looks heaps better than Murphy

Why pick Murphy? Carlton has enough midfielders anyway. Go with Stanton  8)

[pavs nose]

Everyone get off Murphy he won't be worth it. Spend your 550k somewhere else ;)

big call elephant man. murphy scores big, is consistent, still has scope to improve and rarely misses a game. humble pie in the oven on 180 degrees and ready to be serve to you at the completion of round 24. if i am wrong i'll have a slice myself

*cough* sarcasm *cough*

hhaha yeah didnt realise this until after i posted. i am a serial thread skimmer which can lead to missing the point. :-X

[elephants]

Everyone get off Murphy he won't be worth it. Spend your 550k somewhere else ;)

big call elephant man. murphy scores big, is consistent, still has scope to improve and rarely misses a game. humble pie in the oven on 180 degrees and ready to be serve to you at the completion of round 24. if i am wrong i'll have a slice myself

*cough* sarcasm *cough*

hhaha yeah didnt realise this until after i posted. i am a serial thread skimmer which can lead to missing the point. :-X

Hahah no worries. If people are seriously jumping off Murphy after this then they need some real help imo... :)

[R.Griffen]

Everyone get off Murphy he won't be worth it. Spend your 550k somewhere else ;)

big call elephant man. murphy scores big, is consistent, still has scope to improve and rarely misses a game. humble pie in the oven on 180 degrees and ready to be serve to you at the completion of round 24. if i am wrong i'll have a slice myself

*cough* sarcasm *cough*

hhaha yeah didnt realise this until after i posted. i am a serial thread skimmer which can lead to missing the point. :-X

Hahah no worries. If people are seriously jumping off Murphy after this then they need some real help imo... :)

I took Murphy out lol because I thought you blokes we're being serious he is now a lock in my side

[elephants]

Hahaha the kid is a dead set gun. If anyone was to pay any attention to the 'real stats' he actually racked up 92 points for every 100 minutes he spent on the field. That will still add up to over 100 in a game where he got a harder than usual tag from a tighter than usual tagger in Picken.
I am keen to watch him stand up and be counted in the DT world this year.

[pavs nose]

would love to have murphy but want gibbs from the start as i think he is going to absolutely explode this year! murphy will join his blue gagger team mate later in the year in my team

[danger]

murph is locked for me.. did me all sorts of favours last year

[alex87]

I dont think Gibbs will go to that next level this year. Better options in better teams. Selwood, Mitchell, Swan, Pendles etc etc.
Gibbs still has the risk of a tagging role. Better going with a proven performer.