Selwood or Swan

[ScoreGasm]

Recent events or making me think twice about picking Dane Swan. He has looked a little under done in the NAB Cup and his comments in the papers speak for themselves. Thus I am thinking about trading him for Joel Selwood. Thoughts?

[S_Coach99]

What comments, do you have a link, I missed those comments, wouldnt mind reading them...

I find Dane Swan to be a half assed in his approach to comments to the media, I wouldn't read too much into it.

He's a proven gun, and I think he is slightly under priced.

I'd be making room for both mate!

[ScoreGasm]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-star-dane-swan-sets-2014-as-his-retirement-date/story-e6frf9jf-1226278748909

It seems like he is thinking bout retirement already. He just seems like he doesn't care this season. I already have GAJ, Thompson and Gibbs as my premiums. So it's between Selwood and Swan for my Other premium.

[S_Coach99]

Yeah, I reckon thats the way he approaches the media...I wouldnt read into it..

Selwood and Swan... I'd go Swan - just.

[Jukes]

Farking hell, Swan by a mile. Why does everybody hate on Swanny this season? Has been the best dt'er for the last few years and will continue that reign.

[underdog11]

To me that article says he doesnt want to one of those players like James McDonald desperate to hang on to there footy

[its me lads]

if you do trade him dont get selwood.

[Windigo]

if you do trade him dont get selwood.

+1. I currently have both.

Only players I'd oust Swan for are; GAJ, Rockliff, Pendles or Boyd.

[Zombie2.5]

Probaly swan (He just doesnt care about  NAB cup)

but i reckon selwood is a little underpriced and going into season as captain he'll improve for sure

[owenbond007]

Swan is a DTer god id pay 700k thats how underpriced he is.