Everyones thinking it....

[The_Captain]

Who will you be selecting as your 4th ruckman?

[SydneyRox]

I cant see stephenson scoring enough to be number 3 ruck so 4th it is

[The_Captain]

so will you be having redden or just stephenson?

[The_Captain]

seems like a lot of people are 50/50 of these two.. Decisions decisions...

[fertalong]

I think Redden will be a better cash cow and should get games early, but the question is where he sits when Renuof and Lobbe are both back? Renuof is apparently going to be ready for r1 with Lobbe 5-7 weeks away.
Big O on the other hand, has slightly better JS, most probably playing 2nd fiddle to West. He will make probably make cash slower, but will probably earnt more total cash come bye/upgrade time.

Either way, I have both right now since im fielding Giles.

[Zombie2.5]

I think Redden will be a better cash cow and should get games early, but the question is where he sits when Renuof and Lobbe are both back? Renuof is apparently going to be ready for r1 with Lobbe 5-7 weeks away.
Big O on the other hand, has slightly better JS, most probably playing 2nd fiddle to West. He will make probably make cash slower, but will probably earnt more total cash come bye/upgrade time.

Either way, I have both right now since im fielding Giles.

Agreed, Reddens JS might not be so great with renouf coming back and they have enough backup in stewart westoff and i think someone else, he is impressing though so he might get some games but stephenson has more JS

[m-ry]

I think Redden will be a better cash cow and should get games early, but the question is where he sits when Renuof and Lobbe are both back? Renuof is apparently going to be ready for r1 with Lobbe 5-7 weeks away.
Big O on the other hand, has slightly better JS, most probably playing 2nd fiddle to West. He will make probably make cash slower, but will probably earnt more total cash come bye/upgrade time.

Either way, I have both right now since im fielding Giles.

Agreed, Reddens JS might not be so great with renouf coming back and they have enough backup in stewart westoff and i think someone else, he is impressing though so he might get some games but stephenson has more JS

+1 giles on field until byes are done :)then up grade to next best ruck man. starting with cox-y baby

[The F.A.R.K.]

im tempted to play giles, redden, jenkins and stewart

giles garunteed 70 av and 22 games

and surely the other three could ave decent and play most games

[elephants]

Keen on Jenkins I reckon. Wouldn't work with Jacobs and Giles too so for this reason I am looking at Rowe despite is average performance on the weekend. He was in an around it from what I saw.