Opinions on Beau Waters vs Rhys Shaw vs Guerra or Harry Taylor

[whynot102]

Best defender

Other backs Goodard, Birchall, Heath Shaw, Lake, Marty Clarke, B Ellis   Bugg & Wilkes

Thoughts or any other suggestions

[CrowsFan]

So going by your options you have around 415k to spend. In all honesty I don't like any of those options. Waters can score well when fit, but always the risk of getting an injury. Shaw, Guerra and Taylor don't fancy me either.

If you can stretch your budget I would grab Hanley at 447k. Alternatively staying in your budget range you could take a risk on Matty Jaensch, looks like he could be in a good year. Not really anyone else around that price who I find all that tempting

[MC]

As risky as it may be, i'd take Grimes before any of those blokes.

Or, downgrade Lake to a rookie and buy a prem!

[Jay]

clarke-->darley then get heppell? :)