spent alot of time here would love some feedback

[sutho111]

Backs: goddard shaw broughton schoenmakers lake ellis bugg - morris darley
Centres: ablett selwood thomas bartel mccarthy magner - gibson neale
Rucks: cox hmac - redden rowe
Fwds: franklin fyfe chapman rioli porpa devon smith saad - cooyou j cameron

[felsty]

B: why schoey? surely there is someone better
M: awesome line but be wary. good rooks are in the mids and you only have 3 spots for them....
R: set and forget - perfect!
F: not a fan of chappy and his hammies, hopefully porp doesnt pop a shoulder!

all in all an 8.5/10
really why schoey?

also rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50071.0.html

[tor01doc]

Feisty,

Had to laugh - why Shoey.

Maybe it's just a case of mistaken identity - Luke Shuey?  ;D

[felsty]

but really, WHY SCHOEY?!?! i dont get it.. am i missing something? is he the next big thing? does every man and his dog have him and i dont? is he a relation to luke shuey?! really... why?

[Ringo]

Def: Concern with Schoenmakers .  Will he play all games. maybe better options at around same price. 3 prems sharing Round 13 bye.
Mids: maybe a little too strong
Rucks - Solid
Forwards: Sound
Consider downgrading a Prem mid and upgrading Schoenmakers or Porps.

[fever]

b: lol shoey etc
m: agree with others it;s too strong/too much cash used there
r: have to have giles, this years z smith. replace rowe
f: fine

[sutho111]

alright alright im over shoey! just watched him start of this year and thought he might be a good ruffy think his kicking has improved, now i think of it hawks have alot more established defenders in front of him so he probably wont play!