First players clicked on

[verda32]

Which are the 3 players in each position (2 for ruck) that you must have selected for round1 to have any chance of winning?

[verda32]

Ive had a crack and said: Def- Goddard, Newman, Lake
                                   Mid- Ablett, Swan, Priddis
                                   Ruck- Mummy, Luey
                                   Fwd- Buddy, Goodes, Pavlich

[scotty_222]

def- goddard,shaw,dids
mid- gablett,swan,pendles
ruck- cox,mummy
for- goodes,buddy,fyfe

[ZEDDOG]

Good question.
Having a think, the top must haves are not necessarily the 3 best.
Isn't it right that selecting the best rookie is just as (or more ) important than the right premium.
What's the point of 3 good premis if you pick did cash cow.

Example ruck
'best' I would say cox and mummy, however with lieu, mcevoy sandi etc there is lots of options at the top.
But if you don't pick orren and Giles then you could be cooked with no growth or cover on bench

With this in Mind,
my must haves are:
Ruck, orren and Giles
Fwd: buddy ,  treloar, hall  but, zorko, if fit
Mid ablett, Magner, and maybe coniglio
Back Goddard, Hargrave and best rookie

Remember this is not the top scoring 11 players butter players that generate a good skeleton to give Pts and cash
Thoughts? ?

[BundyOP]

first 3 in teame before any changes were

back: goddard, delidio, shaw
mids: ablett, selwood, hayes
rucks: big o, giles
fwds: buddy, goodes, stevie j

[Spite]

I'm pretty sure the winner of last years SC using the "NO GODDARD" strategy would laugh at this topic, but here are my thoughts never the less:

Back: Goddard, Deledio, Ellis
Mids: Ablett, Selwood, Magner
Rucks: Mumford, Giles
Forwards: Buddy, Goodes, Smith

[cortez]

backs: Goddard deledio broughton
mids: ablett, swan, selwood
ruck: mummy, giles
Forwards: Buddy, Fyfe, Rioli

couple of different pickd but hey if we all had the same thoughts it would be a pretty boring season.

[enzedder]

Goddard, Deledio, Broughton
Ablett, Swan, Selwood
Cox, Mummy
Buddy, Goodes, Chapman

[MC]

Back: Goddard, Shaw, Clarke
Mids: Ablett, Pendles, Shiel
Rucks: Cox, Giles, Stephenson
Fwd: Buddy, Martin, Sidebottom.

All must haves in some way imo - perhaps barring Clarke (fitness)

[Capper]

backs - Goddard, Heater, Lake
mids - Swan, GAJ, Boyd
ruck - Cox, Sandi
fwd - Buddy, Goodes, Chappy

Only change i have made is Chappy in for Stevie J purely just for the $$$$$

[Footyrulz]

DEF:
Goddard, Deledio, Darley

MID:
Ablett, Selwoood, Shiel

RUC:
Mummy, Giles

FOR:
Buddy, Fyfe, D Smith

[coolfugitiv0]

DEF: Goddard, Lids, Shaw
MID: GAJ, Selwood,
RUC: Mummy, Leuy
FWD: Buddy, Fyfe, Martin

I only chose two from the mids - I believe those two are the only must-haves.

GAJ being number one must-have in the comp IMO.

[mt_williams22]

Nice Question!

Def: Goddard, Scotland, Ellis
Mids: Ablett, Murphy, Hayes
Rucks: Kruezer, Giles
Forwards: Buddy, Goodes, Sidebottom