The aging proven star vs. The 2nd year young gun?

[Jay]

Which rnd 12 bye- defender that isnt shaw or broughton should be in my side? Ive narrowed it down to enright and heppel!

Please vote :)

[Ringo]

Voted Heppell but not a load of confidence.

Heppell - Will he suffer from 2nd year syndrome or will he be the one to break the tradition. Also he is the rising star and none of the recent winners have improved in secong years. (Hanneberry, Rich, Palmer) Selwood was the last one in 2008.

Enright SC score average have been dropping by 1 or 2 points per year over the last couple of years.

IMO Enright will maintain 90 points average but Heppell if he can shake the syndrome may average 95+

[bkimm32]

Fyfe, Martin, Rockliffe, Trengove are all players who improved immensely in their second years. If Heppell is as smart a player as we think he is their is no reason he can't improve out of sight in his second year also.

[enzedder]

Enright's pattern of dropping points is a worry...for that reason Heppell...he's a big lad who should keep improving.

[MontyJnr]

If geelong start to drop off, will enright see more of it in the backline though?

I find it laughable the amount of people considering Heppell. Seriously overpriced. People think just because Fyfe beat the second year blues, everyone will start doing it now. Heppell will not be a top 7 defender this season.

[fever]

with his start to the year i prefer reg grundy, or eski. but of the two enright for me, unless you can use the leftover cash elsewhere