Eveyone Loves A Poll....Right? - RUCKMENS

Started by Colliwobblers, March 06, 2012, 10:39:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which 4 Ruckman will be in your round 1 Side?

Cox
17 (53.1%)
Goldstein
1 (3.1%)
Sandilands
12 (37.5%)
Mumford
24 (75%)
Burger
15 (46.9%)
Mcevoy
14 (43.8%)
Jacobs
10 (31.3%)
Hille
1 (3.1%)
Martin
0 (0%)
Ryder
1 (3.1%)
Minson
6 (18.8%)
Jolly
1 (3.1%)
NicNat
1 (3.1%)
Clarke
0 (0%)
Warnoch
1 (3.1%)
Z Smith
1 (3.1%)
Jamar
0 (0%)
Hale
0 (0%)
Bailey
0 (0%)
West
1 (3.1%)
Kruezer
4 (12.5%)
HMAC
26 (81.3%)
B Renouf
0 (0%)
Maric
3 (9.4%)
Cordy
1 (3.1%)
Longer
0 (0%)
Derickx
2 (6.3%)
Giles
76 (237.5%)
Redden
45 (140.6%)
Stephensen
53 (165.6%)
Rowe
4 (12.5%)
J JENKINS
4 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 32

Football Factory

Really hard choice picking the 4th ruck .. Orren,Redden and Jenkins ... i went Redden

burner11

Quote from: stew42 on March 07, 2012, 06:36:09 PM
Don't believe that less than a quarter of people have Giles...

That's over 75% of people we don't have to worry about Stew making money on cash cows ;-)

Ziplock

*yawn* because you can vote 4 times, the true % is actually multiplied by 4. So, close to everyone has giles :P

mezzoculo

Quote from: Ziplock on March 07, 2012, 06:59:13 PM
*yawn* because you can vote 4 times, the true % is actually multiplied by 4. So, close to everyone has giles :P
???
You can't chose the same player four times, so how's that? If one quarter of respondants selected Giles as one of their four choices then he would have 25% selection. If Giles was selected by half of the people as one of their choices then he would show 50% selection and so on...
So, yeah, what?

Ziplock

members voted- 60
giles votes- 54

enough said.

PowerBug

Very spread out poll here. Surprised Redden has so much love. When i mentioned him in October he was known by no-body. Goodbye another potential smokey. :P

Colliwobblers

Yeah he sure put his hand up last week in the NAB CUP, another test vs Sadni this week and if he stands up again with lobbe out he will be in 90% of good teams :)

Ehat the votes tell me is MOST people are not going dual premiums....

Interesting compating the FF poll, to the ownership % on DT, COX is the most picked ruck there by a fair way...

TheMailman

Happy that many people are jumping away from Cox/Mumford/Jacobs/Burger onto Mcintosh   :P

mezzoculo

Quote from: Ziplock on March 07, 2012, 07:38:38 PM
members voted- 60
giles votes- 54

enough said.
Too true. Forgive my brain f@rt.  :)

Zombie2.5

Right now thinking
1. McEvoy
2. H-Mac (McMac ;D)
3. Giles
4. Jenkins

But might change it to 3 rooks
McEvoy, Giles, Jenkins, Stephenson

or if 2 premo
McEvoy, Jacobs, Giles, Jenkins

Colliwobblers

69 votes 63 Giles we have a winner and no surprises there.

Oh and McEvoy is a great pick Zombie2.5, I am starting to buy into the fear campaign on Mummy, carry over points towards his next suspension, a hard at it player he is going to be great this season but i'm not sure i want to go without my #1 ruck for even 2 rounds if he gets suspended again.

Sandi will be rested, Cox will up fwd but will probably still score well enough.

Hmmmm, my front runners for selection at the moment (not counting rooks)

1. McEvoy
2. Jacobs
3. Minson
4. Kroooze
5. HMac

Of them I am not sure I trust HMac to go as well with Goldy in full time. Not sure I want to pay for McEvoy or Jacobs if the other two continue to impress. "scratches head"  ??? damn rucks

ScoreGasm

Big O didn't look to good in his last NAB game so he is out for Redden. I'm a bit concerned about Redden once Renouf and Lobbe are back to full fitness though. Have also gone McEvoy over Sandi purely because it looks like McEvoy is going to see more game time.

Colliwobblers

Couldn't agree more, really concerned about all the Sandi talk out of Freo thus far

T Dog

I thought Maric may have been more popular. I have him and Kreuzer in mind with Redden and Giles. Frees up the cash but it is not the mummy berger team I started with.

Colliwobblers

Quote from: T Dog on March 09, 2012, 11:14:23 AM
I thought Maric may have been more popular. I have him and Kreuzer in mind with Redden and Giles. Frees up the cash but it is not the mummy berger team I started with.

I Have Jacobs - 3 rooks in DT, but in SC at the moment I have Minson - Kruze - 2 rooks..... Not anything like what i started with either.

I'm still not sure about the rucks at this stage but the one thing I am sure of is it won't be 2-2 Gun Rook this year