rate for a rate?

[gotheroos!]

hey guys,
here's my team. i'll rate urs too!

goddard scotland shaw broughton hargrave ellis tomilson (webberley darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson kerridge neale (gibson magner)
mumford giles (redden stephenson)
franklin goodes fyfe dangerfield sidebottom d.smith pfeiffer (zorko smedts)

thoughts? thx!

[quinny88]

Backline is solid.
i like the risk of watson in the mids, has potential to be great if he stays injury free
rucks.. good choice of players for a prem/rookie approach, hopefully it pays off for you
forwards solid

8.5

Please rate mine
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,49959.0.html

[felsty]

Solid side all round
My only concern would be the rookie ruck. Giles hasn't shown enough to be picked on the field in my opinion. Other than that a perfect side! Kerridge will be a gun if he doesn't get the vest! Watson should be a great pick
Maybe take money out of forwards and upgrade to a h.mac kruze west?
Rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,49811.15.html

[gotheroos!]

yeh thx guys. the ruck department is a slight worry. but i'm sure that giles will do well. if not, i can always downgrade fyfe and use money to upgrade to mcintosh / west

[quinny88]

If you want to bulk up the ruck then i wouldnt use fyfe as the downgrade, he is a gun.
I would downgrade hargrave and either danger or sidey

[gotheroos!]

ok, but do u reckon fyfe is overpriced? in that case i might downgrade sidebottom.

or would it be worthwhile goign with only 3 gun mids and 3 rookies and get cash there?

[Jay]

Backs: solid
Mids: solid again
Ruc: bit of a worry but i think redden might be good enough for R2, so could work
Fwd: again very good

Id love to offer some constructive criticism but i cant think of any...a very good unique team...9/10

Rate mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48411.60.html :)

[fever]

If you want to bulk up the ruck then i wouldnt use fyfe as the downgrade, he is a gun.
I would downgrade hargrave and either danger or sidey

agree with quinny. mcintosh over west too imo.