Chappy vs fyfe

[aces-high]

Have buddy locked in with dusty, sidey, christensen, saad and pfeiffer as the starters in my forward line. For my other premium i cant decide out of chappy and fyfe. Who will be the better option and why? Cheers

[yangers95]

well firstly, this is just me but i don't really like having two of the same team in the same area of the pitch (chappy n christy), but that may just be me.

heaps of people seem to be writing off chappy, combination of age and geelong's resting system. but he should still score ok.
however in short, fyfe is a gun. if you have the money i reckon u should choose one of fyfe, pav and goodes. fyfe is the choice for me, can't really see him dropping averages, whilst u can see chappy drop averages.

[Justin Bieber]

What about buddy?

[owenbond007]

chappy is the man. Christo is a terrible pick. I dont understand all the love for him. Doubt he will become premo. Better options out there for mid pricers.

[MGK1]

Fyfe! he is such a gun. Plus Chappy will be rested you would think in some of the matches..

[aces-high]

Okay cheers for all that guys :P swapped a few players around, the forwards look like this now
Buddy, fyfe, robinson, dusty, steeele, saad and pfeiffer
So im going fyfe and robbo instead of chappy and christo or even gray.

[Grannyboy]

Out with the old n in with the new. Chappy used to pick himself now the new guard seems to be taking over. Fyfe all the way.