Balanced or Bland..

Started by danger, March 06, 2012, 02:19:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

danger

Any pointers?

Rooks will be finalised prior to round one.

BACKS:
Goddard, Carrazo, Suckling, Heppel, Mackie, Conca, Bugg, Wilkes, Baguley

MIDS:
Mitchell, Selwood, Watson, Dangerfield, Ebert, Treloar, Zorko, Magner

RUCKS:
Sandilands, Giles, Derickx, Stephenson

FORWARDS:
Franklin, Cloke, Higgins, Nahas, Christensen, Porplyzia, Cooyou, Kerridge, Hall

yorgis

sorry but very bland. danger, ebert in mid? . no, way too many mid pricers in your team

crowborr

Sorry mate not a fan. too many risks in there if you ask me.

Mackie is a bit hit and miss.
Correct me if i'm wrong but i think conca won't play the rest of this pre season, so it's a tough call to slot him in. I am a big fan of delids and shaw over carrots as he sometimes gets stuck with a tagging role. Someone like hargrave at this stage would be better in the backs.

Mids are a weak spot. Watson if he can stay on the park would be a great choice but it's pretty iffy. Danger and Ebert I'm not sold on. Sure danger will improve but by how much?? not sure.

Rucks are standard, but i do recall reading that ross lyon said sandilands will be looked after throughout the season so he may miss a game or two.

Fwds Higgins and Porps in the same lineup is not such a good idea as they'll be competing with each other on how many games they can miss each season. Not that i can really talk as i currently have gray and porps in my team. Maybe sliding dustin martin or nat fyfe in there could make it look better.

That was probably pretty critical haha sorry mate. Any coin left over??

Mr.Craig

Well, it's different I'll give you that.

Not having at least 1 out of Swan, Pendles and Ablett just seems like DT suicide. You've got too much cash sitting in your backline, I'd suggest downgrading Mackie to Clarke or a rookie (Darley?). Then you'd have the cash to turn Dangerfield into a premium and Nahas or Higgins into Martin or Sidebottom.

I don't mind the Ebert pick. Hargrave seems like a better choice atm compared to Conca.

danger

Thanks guys, some solid feedback there.
I've made some changes, probably not the last before round one..

Not sure bout the ruck choice.. Much happier with the Mids :D

DEF:
Goddard, Carrazo, Suckling, Heppel, Armstrong, Bugg, Darley, Wilkes, Baguley

MID:
Swan, Mitchell, Murphy, Selwood, Kerridge, Magner, Clifton, Smith

RUCK:
Mumford, Giles, Rowe, Stephenson

FOR:
Franklin, Fyfe, Cloke, O'Keefe, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Pfeiffer, Horlin-Smith, Hall

Thoughts?

danger


C.Judd3Votes

Very, very risky, IMO won't pay off. Use these other guys advice and make some changes.

danger

OK more changes, thanks again..

Feeling better about this mob..

B: Goddard, Deledio, Carrazo, Suckling, Heppel, Bugg, Darley      Wikes, Baguley
M: Swan, Mitchell, Murphy, Selwood, Kerridge, Magner      Newell, Smith
R: Mumford, Giles    Stephenson, Rowe
F: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Pfeiffer     Horlin-Smith, Hall