Mid price defenders

Started by underdog11, March 05, 2012, 07:52:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hargrave vs. Conca vs. Duffield vs. Lake vs. Other

Hargrave
26 (59.1%)
Conca
3 (6.8%)
Duffield
7 (15.9%)
Lake
1 (2.3%)
Other
4 (9.1%)
None
3 (6.8%)

Total Members Voted: 3

underdog11

Mid price defenders. its been talked about a lot over the last few weeks. Currently dont have a mid pricer in my entire team, got a killer trade plan! Anyway which mid pricer/s are you going with in the backline?

Matt_352

thinking of going 1-2 of duffman and hargrave

BC2010

Backs are the only place where i have mid-pricers (3 of them).
Brodie Smith
Ryan Hargrave
Courtenay Dempsey

Justin Bieber

If you have none then your not serious on winning DT.

Torpedo10

Hargrave looks very solid. I reckon he is the best choice. Conca is a smoky.

Windigo


underdog11

Quote from: whatlez on March 05, 2012, 08:22:02 PM
If you have none then your not serious on winning DT.

why do you say that whatlez, got a really good plan that i dont think fanfooty focus on enough and part of it is 4 guns and 3 rookies in the back. I think conca or lake/hargrave might be worth it, but conca's not proven enough for me and lake or hargrave is too risky, but if i went for one it would be lake or hargrave, you dont have to have mid pricers if you have faith in your rooks and guns stratergy.

fertalong

Quote from: underdog11 on March 05, 2012, 08:38:44 PM
Quote from: whatlez on March 05, 2012, 08:22:02 PM
If you have none then your not serious on winning DT.

why do you say that whatlez, got a really good plan that i dont think fanfooty focus on enough and part of it is 4 guns and 3 rookies in the back. I think conca or lake/hargrave might be worth it, but conca's not proven enough for me and lake or hargrave is too risky, but if i went for one it would be lake or hargrave, you dont have to have mid pricers if you have faith in your rooks and guns stratergy.

True dat! If you get your stanley, heppel and puopolo of 2011 for rookies then you have potential keepers and make better use of your cash. However, I voted hargrave as he's looking tasty right now.

Justin Bieber

@underdog, yeah I didn't mean to say it like that, I'm meant you need risks and if your not at least considering Hargrave or considering Giles as number 2 ruck then I believe you will not compeitive for overall. You might go alright, but maybe not under 1k.

underdog11

Quote from: whatlez on March 05, 2012, 08:51:51 PM
@underdog, yeah I didn't mean to say it like that, I'm meant you need risks and if your not at least considering Hargrave or considering Giles as number 2 ruck then I believe you will not compeitive for overall. You might go alright, but maybe not under 1k.

I do have giles as my second ruck. My risk is my "plan". My theory on mid pricers is there are one/two really good ones going around each year, and there are 4/5 really good rookies, and by my calculations that makes it less risky, but in a way still risky. Obviously have a unique pick like Shiels, Rockliff, Redden and Fyfe could really help your ranking, but there are heaps of mid pricers that burn, and i have been on the recieving end for the last two years, with Liam Anthony and Chris Masten and i had Grimes and Brown, but it was like a sign that they re-injured themselves, so for now no mid pricers for me, unless hargrave keeps his rare form

Justin Bieber

Quote from: underdog11 on March 05, 2012, 09:00:36 PM
Quote from: whatlez on March 05, 2012, 08:51:51 PM
@underdog, yeah I didn't mean to say it like that, I'm meant you need risks and if your not at least considering Hargrave or considering Giles as number 2 ruck then I believe you will not compeitive for overall. You might go alright, but maybe not under 1k.

I do have giles as my second ruck. My risk is my "plan". My theory on mid pricers is there are one/two really good ones going around each year, and there are 4/5 really good rookies, and by my calculations that makes it less risky, but in a way still risky. Obviously have a unique pick like Shiels, Rockliff, Redden and Fyfe could really help your ranking, but there are heaps of mid pricers that burn, and i have been on the recieving end for the last two years, with Liam Anthony and Chris Masten and i had Grimes and Brown, but it was like a sign that they re-injured themselves, so for now no mid pricers for me, unless hargrave keeps his rare form

Well I can tell you that Hargrave is my only mid pricer. But he will gun it.

PowerBug

I see you ask alot of questions underdog. I've got an idea for you on this one:

Pick them all!! 5 mid-priced backline FTW!! (With Goddard and Shaw) >:D

underdog11

Quote from: PowerBug on March 05, 2012, 11:32:17 PM
I see you ask alot of questions underdog. I've got an idea for you on this one:

Pick them all!! 5 mid-priced backline FTW!! (With Goddard and Shaw) >:D

I just ask what's begging to be asked just to give some perspective to the ff world.

PowerBug

nice. :) Not having a go at you for doing it, was just wondering. :) Keep them coming.

Holz

Quote from: PowerBug on March 05, 2012, 11:32:17 PM
I see you ask alot of questions underdog. I've got an idea for you on this one:

Pick them all!! 5 mid-priced backline FTW!! (With Goddard and Shaw) >:D

im looking at a Goddard, Shaw, Malceski, Duffield, Hargreave, Clarke, Ellis backline