Duffield or Broughton?

[Adamant]

Have 430k to spend, backline looks like this:

Goddard, Shaw, Birchall, ???, Hargrave, Clarke, Ellis (Bugg, Darley)

Duffield: averaged 89 & 87 in 09 & '10, 70k cheaper than Broughts.
Broughton: A rollercoaster last year, role is really unknown, but if playing midfield will pump out 90-100+.

Thoughts?

[Justin Bieber]

I like broughts. Not a fan of the duff man...

[Just Clancy]

Would probs go Brought if i could afford, however can only afford Duffield. Broughton probably won't play mid this year like he did tonight, though.

[pavs nose]

Hard to say how players coming back in will effect both of these guys. Silvagni, lower, barlow, mundy, pav, sandi and morabito(eventually).

Picking these 2 will either pay off big time or screw you over.

[j959]

Hard to say how players coming back in will effect both of these guys. Silvagni, lower, barlow, mundy, pav, sandi and morabito(eventually).

Picking these 2 will either pay off big time or screw you over.

+1 - too early to call still.

the problem with Broughts is that he's such a good utility and will likely be called upon to be a lock-down defender which will pull him out of the mids and crush his fantasy scoring potential ...  :(