Murphy vs Dal Santo vs Mitchell vs Judd vs Gibbs

[Jay]

Murphy- was tagged out of the game tonight which has given me some doubts! He might get the no. 1 tag over juddy...young, consistent and a good scorer

Dal- very consistent scorer, and unique!

Mitchell- pretty much had a breakout year last year...what will he do this year?

Judd- superstar, but has injury troubles

Gibbs- set for a good year

[ando_10]

bit harsh on murphy.
copped tags last year and didnt affect him remember its only nab cup he will average 115-120 this year easily.

but i have voted nicky dal a good unique who is always consistent

[Colliwobblers]

yeah don't measure his stats from NAB CUP manage his care-factor :) Murph of those for me

[Ringo]

Assuming you already have G Ablett.

[MC]

Wow, how quickly the tide turns!  ::)

Why Boyd over NDS?

Is he in a better side? No.
Historically scored more? No. (Nowhere near)
Is age a factor? No. (Dal is 2 years younger)
Did he average more last season? No.
Is he much cheaper? No.
Better JS? No.

So the only question that remains is: wtf?

NDS - What has NDS done for people to be so critical? Oh, apart from averaging 115+ and only missing 3 games in 8 seasons.... 

Only to be shot down/ignored by most people. Now the poll suggests more people are in favour of NDS!
Amazing how one NAB cup game has changed the public perception. How ridiculous.

[Jay]

Assuming you already have G Ablett.

Yeah already have gablett

[j959]

sorry to be blunt, but this is a no-brainer.

Murphy is on the up, NDS was at his ceiling last year

Judd is a superstar but with his pre-season inj rehab would probably be a better mid-season upgrade target.

Mitchell is like NDS, had a blinder last year and more likely to slide than improve.

tough between Murphy and Gibbs = both young and on the up ...

what separates them for me is that Ratts has tended to use Gibbs as a 'utility' type player, cos of his skill set, size, etc he can be used, back, mid and fwd - it is this unknown that would have me leaning towards Murphy, just shading Gibbs ...

[kilbluff1985]

Yep Murphy for me Judd might get rested a bit more up forward this year and give Murphy more of a go.

[Jay]

Toss up between murph & NDS at the moment