Sydeny Swans with Mark Seaby

[R.Griffen]

I currently have Mummy in as my number 1 ruck. I know it is only NAB Cup but John Longmire keeps playing Seaby and if that happens in the real season will Mummy be affected??? or is Seaby only going to play the NAB cup this season???

[SydneyRox]

woulnt read too much into the NAB time. Mummy is the number 1 ruckman at the swans. I am not sure who will get the back up gig this year though. Last year we floated through white and LRT, this year Seaby might see some more game time?

[jabroni]

yeah as per the latest trend among managers - mumfords workload will be managed

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-sport/swans-to-manage-mumfords-workload-20120302-1u810.html

[TheMailman]

yeah as per the latest trend among managers - mumfords workload will be managed

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-sport/swans-to-manage-mumfords-workload-20120302-1u810.html

That says his preseason will be managed, not his AFL season.

As per what SR said, Mumford is the Swans main ruck and will be for the whole of the season barring injury/suspension. He had more % TOG then Cox did. Seaby might play a handful of games but the Swans were pretty reluctant to play 2 specialist ruckman last year. Longmuire has to at least play Seaby in the preseason to make sure he's all in check

[Capper]

Mummy will be the number 1 rucks for the swans but to use him as your number 1 ruck is a no from me.

It kills me as a swans supporter but he will miss some time due to injury, resting and brain fade suspensions.

[Windigo]

Ah well. You'll get that with him.

No way I'm getting Seaby.....The classic day when he he jumped up, got the hit out on the opening bounce...+1....On the way down he broke his ankle.  8)

I had him too.  ::)

[SydneyRox]

Mummy will be the number 1 rucks for the swans but to use him as your number 1 ruck is a no from me.

It kills me as a swans supporter but he will miss some time due to injury, resting and brain fade suspensions.

SC i dont think you can go wrong with mummy, but for DT I havent been sold, think more likely Cox/berger

[jabroni]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/132071/default.aspx

might be happening this week

[SydneyRox]

I like the idea!

Purely as a team I think Seaby is a much better overall option for backup ruck/floating fwd than White/Pyke and prefer to stay in defense.

It may even help Mummy SC/DT scores? We all keep talking about Cox/Nic Nat, but they have forged a great combination and it hasnt done Cox any issues with the way he goes about it.

[Ricochet]

Ah well. You'll get that with him.

No way I'm getting Seaby.....The classic day when he he jumped up, got the hit out on the opening bounce...+1....On the way down he broke his ankle.  8)

I had him too.  ::)

I had him that day as well! never again

[Windigo]

Ah well. You'll get that with him.

No way I'm getting Seaby.....The classic day when he he jumped up, got the hit out on the opening bounce...+1....On the way down he broke his ankle.  8)

I had him too.  ::)

I had him that day as well! never again

Haha. I think the week before he gunned for a 120+ I think.  :P

[Ricochet]

Round    Oppt          K          HB          Pos       Mk        HO       Tk          Free         G.B            DT
P1        Carlton           3          8          11          1          14          1                                            46
P2        St Kilda          8          7          15          5          14          2           4/2            1.0            79
1          St Kilda          6          8          14          5          33          0                                            82
2          Adelaide         9          10        19          7          21          6           2/0           2.0             127
3          Richmond       2          5          7           1          11          2             1/3                            30
4          North Melb     2          10        12          0          19          3             1/1                             55
5          West Coast     5          6          11         5          10          3             3/4          0.1              56
6          Brisbane          0          0          0          0           1           0                                               1


God that is depressing haha

[Windigo]

Geez, I don't even wanna look at it!  :P

[Justin Bieber]

He played well against Brisbane ;D

[SydneyRox]

Lets not forget how well he played when Mummy was out last year... rnds 10-15 (bar13)

Mark Seaby: Annual Fantasy Scores
Club: Sydney     Year: 2011     Games: 10
Round Oppt       K HB Pos Mk HO Tk Free  G.B   DT SC
P1  W. Sydney   1   5   6    0   2    3   2/2          23 82 
P1 Gold Coast    4   2   6    4   5    2          1.0   47 124
P2 Collingwood  2   3   5    2   28   2                 54 41
1 Melbourne      1   3   4    1   1     3  2/1           24 45 
10 North Melb.   2   3   5    3   19   5  1/0  1.0    67 61
11 Brisbane       6   7   13   4   24  3   1/0  1.0    87 97 
12 Richmond     13  8   21  5   36  1   4/0   0.1   115 152 - AND 3 brownlow votes
13 Carlton         2   0     2   1  14   3   1/1          33 46
14 Collingwood  6   8   14   5   39  3   2/0          102 105
15 Adelaide       6   6   12   1   28  4   2/1           76 102 

Now, I am ny no means saying that he is a fantasy star, but I would like to see him in the team.