Colliwobblering 1 , 2, 3, which way do we go??

[Colliwobblers]

The 4 teams posted below, really appreciate some thoughts or a vote at least thanks all....

Team 1. 3 premium mids   =   before you vote consider bock as broughton or enright due to the suspension i forgot  :-[



Team 2. 4 premium mids



Team 3. rookie #2 ruck



Team 4. Guns n Rooks alone

[Ringo]

Based on NAB cup form I am seriously considering Reddan as Ruck 3 rather than Giles or Stephenson who imo have not impressed in NAB cup.

[johnnytheboy1]

Even the team projected with the most sc points looks good it has 2 tiger as B8 & B9 you should only have one or the other.
Team 1 has bock in it so i don't like that. So i prefer team 2 as it has 4 prem mids and s.Jacobs as ruck.Also dangerfield & the porps looked good in the nab cup match.

[Capper]

Based on NAB cup form I am seriously considering Reddan as Ruck 3 rather than Giles or Stephenson who imo have not impressed in NAB cup.

I agree, I would rather see Redden at R3 and Giles at R4. Stephenson will play for cats as R2 imo, so Redden a better choice than Stephenson.

But i dont like Mummy as you R1. He wont play every game due to injury and suspension (due to a brain fade).

Which team?? i like team 3 if you fix your rucks

[TheMailman]

I wouldn' be so hasty on Mumford.

He's had a whole off season to knuckle down on his tackling to make way for the strict guidlines, you can't just do that in 1-2 weeks. Same with injury

[Capper]

I wouldn' be so hasty on Mumford.

He's had a whole off season to knuckle down on his tackling to make way for the strict guidlines, you can't just do that in 1-2 weeks. Same with injury

will they rest him through the season as well???

[TheMailman]

I wouldn' be so hasty on Mumford.

He's had a whole off season to knuckle down on his tackling to make way for the strict guidlines, you can't just do that in 1-2 weeks. Same with injury

will they rest him through the season as well???

No, they'd lose games if they did that

[T Dog]

Team 2..very very nice

[Capper]

I wouldn' be so hasty on Mumford.

He's had a whole off season to knuckle down on his tackling to make way for the strict guidlines, you can't just do that in 1-2 weeks. Same with injury

Hey Mailman, Do you think Pike will play more often then Seaby?? Thats the talk that i am hearing

[TheMailman]

I wouldn' be so hasty on Mumford.

He's had a whole off season to knuckle down on his tackling to make way for the strict guidlines, you can't just do that in 1-2 weeks. Same with injury

Hey Mailman, Do you think Pike will play more often then Seaby?? Thats the talk that i am hearing

Well Pyke has had to try and reinvent himself as a Forward option that can ruck. Basically he's trying to make himself the spot that we once thought was destined for Jesse White. So yeah he offers a bit more to Longmuire than Seaby does