Starting RUCKS!

[Justin Bieber]

Im actually considering this. H Mac is killing it and can upgrade after byes.

+1

H Mac and a premo. McIntosh is an absolute bargain.

If it wasnt for the byes i would have locked Leuenberger and McIntosh.

H Mac and Giles, if I do it. Biggest risk, but may pay off.

yep, and can rotate between the likes of Redden, Stephenson, Jenkins (etc) during the season based on opposition until upgrade time. I'm also considering this.  :)

Lol I like your new photo haha

[yorgis]

the 3 rookie  rucks are a definite no no. after watching phillips for gws, i'm sure their 3 rucks will be sharing the load

i e giles phillips and brogan. For the cats, after seeing west so far and the form of hawkins, stephenson may not get the

match time we all thought he may get [ even though he's a mature age recruit ]  i DEF won't get tempted into buying

that set up, i'll be getting the ol' set and forget 2 premos

[Justin Bieber]

the 3 rookie  rucks are a definite no no. after watching phillips for gws, i'm sure their 3 rucks will be sharing the load

i e giles phillips and brogan. For the cats, after seeing west so far and the form of hawkins, stephenson may not get the

match time we all thought he may get [ even though he's a mature age recruit ]  i DEF won't get tempted into buying

that set up, i'll be getting the ol' set and forget 2 premos

Josh Jenkins, Tom derickx and jarred redden?

[Zombie2.5]

Im actually considering this. H Mac is killing it and can upgrade after byes.

+1

H Mac and a premo. McIntosh is an absolute bargain.

If it wasnt for the byes i would have locked Leuenberger and McIntosh.

+1 but thats my ruck right now, not really caring about byes, when it comes ill do whatever i can but cant really be bothered with them

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Too risky for my liking.  At the moment I have Jacobs and McEvoy, and I'm worried about even those two, lol.

LOL
yeah im worried about starting Giles... both of them? now that is VERY risky.... but could very well pull off in the end!

H MAC might not average that much especially with Goldy trying and not being subbed off, he may only reach 70... on a good day :P and Giles is a proven gun, but if GWS rest him... what happens then? :/ you've got a ruck department desperate to score 10  ::)  ::)  ::)

[Hammer11]

I have 220k left in bank. I am happy with my team.
I'm thinking Sandi, Mummy, Hmac (instead of Big O) and Giles.
Can't see Big O in there for the cats. Redden will not start for Power.
Is that an overkill?

[essendon2]

I have 220k left in bank. I am happy with my team.
I'm thinking Sandi, Mummy, Hmac (instead of Big O) and Giles.
Can't see Big O in there for the cats. Redden will not start for Power.
Is that an overkill?

Redden def. Cox today - he'll most likely play Round 1

[JamSainter]

Too risky for my liking.  At the moment I have Jacobs and McEvoy, and I'm worried about even those two, lol.

LOL
yeah im worried about starting Giles... both of them? now that is VERY risky.... but could very well pull off in the end!

H MAC might not average that much especially with Goldy trying and not being subbed off, he may only reach 70... on a good day :P and Giles is a proven gun, but if GWS rest him... what happens then? :/ you've got a ruck department desperate to score 10  ::)  ::)  ::)

70... on a good day? Have you ever seen McIntosh play?

[Windigo]

Too dodgy at this stage. Don't take it step further with Hamish at the one spot.

[yorgis]

giles is not a proven gun, he could not get a game at port, and the only reasons most people have picked him, is because

he looked to be the only ruck for gws and price. altho' he has shown some form in nab. start him on the field at your

peril . i thought phillips played fairly well and they still have broges, so his game time won't be 100%. one of the

best options for emergency

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Too risky for my liking.  At the moment I have Jacobs and McEvoy, and I'm worried about even those two, lol.

LOL
yeah im worried about starting Giles... both of them? now that is VERY risky.... but could very well pull off in the end!

H MAC might not average that much especially with Goldy trying and not being subbed off, he may only reach 70... on a good day :P and Giles is a proven gun, but if GWS rest him... what happens then? :/ you've got a ruck department desperate to score 10  ::)  ::)  ::)

70... on a good day? Have you ever seen McIntosh play?

sarcasm clearly doesn't get through online  ::)

[Slap]

If you were to get Hmac, I'd want to be using him as my second ruck.  He is making a strong case during his NAB games.  I think he'd be suited to a premo/hmac combo.  Then there is the good selection of rookie rucks like stephenson, giles and redden.