How about NO GWS players?

[TheMailman]

Yeah agree too many good options to go NONE.
Surely Giles is a lock regardless of whether he is you 2nd or 3rd ruckmen??

Hopefully he isn't a lock LE  ;)

[elephants]

Hahah true. DOn't get Giles, he is over-rated. Will fail along with the other 40 of the best young footballers in the country.... And Folau ;)

[Zombie2.5]

i Have Bugg(or Darley, not sure), shiel, miles, giles, treloar and hampton right now
and why do so many rookies names rhyme?? miles and giles, neale and shiel

[T Dog]

Thanks for all that. Giles and  McDonald seem likely.. :o Just may be without any other GWS rooks as the season starts.

[Kuruki]

So many people have got Shiel still in there sides. Unless he can fly and wears his underwear outside his shorts, he is not going anywhere near my round 1 side.

[TheMailman]

So many people have got Shiel still in there sides. Unless he can fly and wears his underwear outside his shorts, he is not going anywhere near my round 1 side.

[Mr.Craig]

So many people have got Shiel still in there sides. Unless he can fly and wears his underwear outside his shorts, he is not going anywhere near my round 1 side.

What you said. Sure he has the wraps but you'd want to at least see him run around a bit before using a critical mid rook pick on him.

[TheMailman]

So many people have got Shiel still in there sides. Unless he can fly and wears his underwear outside his shorts, he is not going anywhere near my round 1 side.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/game/matchscores.html?id=3688

He was the best of the GWS midfielders last year

He'd only be taken down 4-5 spots with the recruiting

[Birryfy]

I have 6, and have faith in all of them.

[Colliwobblers]

I have, From the backline,

Bugg
Shiel
Giles
Smith
Treloar

could be more if rooks from other clubs fail to be listed for round 1, i started the team with 8 GWS rooks, but some others outside GWD have shone through, Magner and Neale and Hall just to name a few.

[Spite]

So many people have got Shiel still in there sides. Unless he can fly and wears his underwear outside his shorts, he is not going anywhere near my round 1 side.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/game/matchscores.html?id=3688

He was the best of the GWS midfielders last year

He'd only be taken down 4-5 spots with the recruiting

Josh P. Kennedy scored 274 supercoach points in that match! Shiel scored 9. If my calculator is correct, JPK scored 30 times more than sheil. Woah.

...

Shiels a lock for me still... :)

[nostradamus]

l think it would be a big mistake to go into the season with no GWS rookies, there are so many excellent options in their team

......the trick is picking the best ones

[elephants]

l think it would be a big mistake to go into the season with no GWS rookies, there are so many excellent options in their team

......the trick is picking the best ones

+1 and check your PM's nostra ;)