How about NO GWS players?

[T Dog]

Yes its only NAB cup but really. Are there enough good rookies in other sides?

[mezzoculo]

I have three (Giles and a forward and back rookie).
Not as many GWS rooks as I had GCS rooks last year.
Plenty of other mature age choices.

[Spite]

Ellis
Morris
Smedts
Clarke

Neale,
Magner
Mitchell
Gibson
Wingard
Stephenson
Redden
Derickx
Rowe

Kerridge
Hall
Zorko
Walsh
Pfeiffer
Saad

This was off the top of my head, in less than minute, so to answer your question, yes. :)

[Jukes]

I have three too...in my forward line.

2 in the backs (Darley, Bugg) 1 in the middle (Clifton) 1 ruck (Giles) and 3 forwards (Hampton but may not be there for long, Smith and Cameron).

[Colliwobblers]

haha writing off the GWS rooks already? 10 have scored more than well enough for rooks IMO, with a quarter to go....

[Capper]

atleast Old Mac don ald and Giles should be in everyones team.

but not starting in your lineups

[BBosCo]

hey dont pick any then, more points for me

[Colliwobblers]

considering how much possession footy the hawks played and how NOT - game ready the Giants were, there were a few rooks worth having i think

   Player Name   K   H   D   M   HO   T   FF   FA   SG   G   B   DT
1   Devon Smith   19   8   27   7   0   4   4   2   0   0   2   110
2   Rhys Palmer   8   15   23   4   0   3   1   1   0   0   1   77
3   Stephen Coniglio   14   11   25   3   0   1   0   1   0   0   1   75
4   Josh Bruce           9   8   17   7   1   2   0   1   0   0   0   70
5   Sam Darley    12   4   16   7   0   1   2   1   0   0   0   68
6   Will Hoskin-Elliott   13   0   13   7   0   0   0   1   0   0   1   58
7   Jeremy Cameron   8   5   13   8   0   0   4   2   0   0   1   57
8   Andrew Phillips   11   4   15   4   7   0   2   2   0   0   0   56
9   Israel Folau     6   2   8   4   2   3   1   2   0   1   2   51
10   Jacob Townsend   5   4   9   2   0   4   2   0   0   0   0   47
11   Stephen Clifton   7   2   9   4   0   2   0   0   0   0   0   45
12   Jonathon Giles   5   5   10   2   5   1   3   0   0   0   0   43

[Mr.Craig]

hey dont pick any then, more points for me

+1

[elephants]

I have Giles, Cameron, Hampton, Shiel, McDonald, Darley and Bugg.

However Hogan is looking to push out Shiel or McDonald and depending on the performances of other rookies (like Couch, Wingard and Ellis) this number will probably decrease.

[Capper]

I have Giles, Cameron, Hampton, Shiel, McDonald, Darley and Bugg.

However Hogan is looking to push out Shiel or McDonald and depending on the performances of other rookies (like Couch, Wingard and Ellis) this number will probably decrease.

no room for treloar???

[elephants]

I have Giles, Cameron, Hampton, Shiel, McDonald, Darley and Bugg.

However Hogan is looking to push out Shiel or McDonald and depending on the performances of other rookies (like Couch, Wingard and Ellis) this number will probably decrease.

no room for treloar???

Injured I thought? Was in my initial draft until I saw him rocking a moon-boot...

[TheMailman]

Yes its only NAB cup but really. Are there enough good rookies in other sides?

No, there really isn't. There are a couple of better rookies but really atm spots 4-15 is covered by GWS players

[Justin Bieber]

How some of the gws played today you can't pass them up.

[elephants]

Yeah agree too many good options to go NONE.
Surely Giles is a lock regardless of whether he is you 2nd or 3rd ruckmen??