Sam Gibson, Elliot Yeo or James McDonald???

[nicw98]

I can't decide which rookie i should have in my team this year

[mdub]

I doubt Yeo will get a lot of game time. very light frame probley need another pre season to get into lions starting 22

[Swallow12]

Likewise Gibson is currently on the rookie list, but should be upgraded soon

[Capper]

old mac don ald for me but i currently have him and gibson (bench) in my team

[The Supercoach]

North have 2 spots on their senior list avliable and its almost certain that one of them is going to gibson. depite that i would stick with macdonald unless gibbo continuous to impress in the NAB cup

[2 large cokes]

get on the gibbo train mate. I can see McDonald being this years Shaun Atley

[Obese Arachnid]

get on the gibbo train mate. I can see McDonald being this years Shaun Atley

Well direct comparison is direct comparison, unfortunately on this occasion you fail badly, coz it's not a direct.......
Macca is Harris, it's that simple.

[Mozza3]

get on the gibbo train mate. I can see McDonald being this years Shaun Atley

That's as ridiculous as someone saying that Gibson will be this years Cam Richardson.

[burner11]

McDonald had a sweet average b4 he was "pushed" out by Melb. Ok he's 35 but a year off he's super fit and knows how to get the footy, A shoe in if you ask me